Questions? Call 800-624-6242

| Items in cart [0]

HARDBACK
price:\$49.95

## At What Price?: Conceptualizing and Measuring Cost-of-Living and Price Indexes (2002) Commission on Behavioral and Social Sciences and Education (CBASSE)

### Citation Manager

. "2 Conceptual Foundations for Price and Cost-of-Living Indexes." At What Price?: Conceptualizing and Measuring Cost-of-Living and Price Indexes. Washington, DC: The National Academies Press, 2002.

 Page 84

The following HTML text is provided to enhance online readability. Many aspects of typography translate only awkwardly to HTML. Please use the page image as the authoritative form to ensure accuracy.

At What Price?: Conceptualizing and Measuring Cost-of-Living and Price Indexes

(29)

for some matrix A = [amn] (which must be symmetric and have a single positive eigenvalue), then the Fisher ideal index (8) is exact in the sense that if we calculated the cost function associated with (29) and used it to calculate the COLIs (18), (19) or (24), we would obtain (8) (Byushgens, 1925). If the matrix A has an inverse B, say, the cost function associated with (29) takes the form

(30)

(If A is not invertible, (30) will still lead to the Fisher ideal index.) The demand functions associated with equation (30) can be written in the form

(31)

The remarkable thing about this result is not that it is possible to find a cost function and a set of demand functions that justify a given price index, but the fact that the result is so general. Although preferences (29) are homothetic—and indeed we can see directly from (30) that the cost function is the product of utility and a function of prices, or from (31) that the shares of the budget pnqn/x are independent of x—the matrices A and B are not specified, except that they must be symmetric and have a single nonnegative eigenvalue, a requirement that comes from the general theory of consumer demand and guarantees, among other things, that demand curves slope down. As a result, and always subject to homotheticity, the demand functions (31) allow the consumer to respond to price changes in a general way; the price elasticities of demand from (31) are unrestricted, except by the general restrictions of consumer theory. The Fisher ideal index is therefore exact for a set of preferences and demand functions that do not restrict substitution behavior in ways beyond that required for the theory. It therefore permits a way of computing a general cost-of-living index without having to estimate the demand functions.

Diewert (1976) extended and generalized these results. A particular specification of preferences, or of the cost function, is said to be a second-order flexible functional form if the utility (or cost) function can provide a second-order approximation to an arbitrary utility (or cost) function. A superlative price index is then one that is exact for some second-order flexible functional form for either the cost or utility function but with preferences restricted to be homothetic. Diewert showed that the utility and cost functions (29) and (30) are flexible for homothetic preferences, so that the Fisher ideal index is an example of a superlative index.

 Page 84
 Front Matter (R1-R16) Executive Summary (1-12) 1 Introduction (13-37) 2 Conceptual Foundations for Price and Cost-of-Living Indexes (38-93) 3 Index Domain (94-105) 4 Evolving Market Baskets: Adjusting Indexes to Account for Quality Change (106-154) 5 New Goods and New Outlets (155-177) 6 The Special Case of Medical Services (178-190) 7 Index Design and Index Purpose (191-221) 8 Whose Index? Aggregating Across Households (222-251) 9 Data Collection for CPI Construction (252-282) Appendix: Statistical Definition and Estimation of Price Indexes (283-292) References (293-306) Glossary (307-314) Biographical Sketches of Panel Members and Staff (315-318) Index (319-332)