Questions? Call 888-624-8373

PAPERBACK + PDF
your price: $64.50
add to cart

PAPERBACK
list:$55.00
Web:$49.50
add to cart

PDF BOOK
your price: $42.50
add to cart

PDF CHAPTERS
your price: $5.30
select

Rights & Permissions

topleft topright

Indicators for Waterborne Pathogens (2004)
Board on Life Sciences (BLS)
Water Science and Technology Board (WSTB)

Page
82
bottomleft bottomright

The following HTML text is provided to enhance online readability. Many aspects of typography translate only awkwardly to HTML. Please use the page image as the authoritative form to ensure accuracy.


Indicators for Waterborne Pathogens

TABLE 2-3 Selected Studies Used for Analysis of Health Effects and Microbial Water Quality Relationships in Recreational Waters

Authors

Year

Country

Study Design

Water

Stevenson a,b,c

1953

United States

Randomized controlled Trial

Fresh

Mujeriego et al. a,d

1982

Spain

Retrospective cohort (cross-sectional study)

Marine

Cabelli et al. a,d

1982

United States

Prospective cohort

Fresh, Marine

Cabelli a,b,d

1983

Egypt

Prospective cohort

Marine

Dufour a,d

1984

United States

Prospective cohort

Fresh

Seyfried et al.

1985

Canada

Prospective cohort

Fresh

Fattal et al., UNEP/WHO no. 20 a,c

1987

Israel

Prospective cohort

Marine

Lightfoot

1989

Canada

Prospective cohort

Fresh

Ferley et al. a,b,d

1989

France

Retrospective cohort

Fresh

Cheung et al. a,d

1989

Hong Kong

Prospective cohort

Marine

UNEP/WHO no. 53 a,c,d

1991

Spain

Prospective cohort

Marine

UNEP/WHO no. 46 a,c

1991

Israel

Prospective cohort

Marine

Fewtrell et al. c,e

1992

United Kingdom

Prospective cohort

Fresh

Corbett et al. c,d

1993

Australia

Prospective cohort

Marine

Pike a,b,d

1994

United Kingdom

Prospective cohort (cross-sectional study)

Marine

Kay et al. c

1994

United Kingdom

Randomized controlled Trial

Marine

Medical Research Councilb,d

1995

South Africa

Prospective cohort

Marine

Kueh et al. a

1995

Hong Kong

Prospective cohort

Marine

Bandaranayake c

1995

New Zealand

Prospective cohort

Marine

Van Dijk et al. b

1996

United Kingdom

Prospective cohort

Marine

Haile et al.

1996

United States

Prospective cohort

Marine

Fleisher et al. c

1996

United Kingdom

Randomized controlled Trial

Marine

aControl for less than three confounders reported, or not reported at all.

bExposure not defined as head immersion, head splashing, or water ingestion.

c<1,700 bathers and 1,700 nonbathers participating in the study.

dOnly use of seasonal mean for analysis of association with outcome reported.

eExposure is white-water canoeing, considered similar to swimming, with intake likely.

SOURCE: Adapted from WHO, 1998.

Of the 37 studies evaluated by Prüss, 22 qualified for inclusion in the evaluation. Figure 2-1 presents the relationship between indicator organism density in marine water and illness risk for bathers. A similar compilation of the results for studies in fresh recreational waters is shown in Figure 2-2. Of the 22 studies selected for analysis, 17 were prospective cohort studies, 2 were retrospective

Page
82