The following HTML text is provided to enhance online
readability. Many aspects of typography translate only awkwardly to HTML.
Please use the page image
as the authoritative form to ensure accuracy.
Saving Lives, Buying Time: Economics of Malaria Drugs in an Age of Resistance
expensive and do not discriminate between a true clinical case of malaria and illness of another cause in someone with a chronic but asymptomatic malaria infection, which is common in high-transmission areas. Work is progressing toward appropriate rapid diagnostics for such areas, but validated tests are not yet available.
Difficulties Related to International Aid Programs
The main purpose of bilateral and multilateral aid is to provide benefits to nations (or groups within them) who have been identified as appropriate beneficiaries of the particular type of assistance given. A global subsidy takes away the opportunity to select beneficiaries. In the case of ACTs, this means that some nations as well as certain individuals within virtually every nation will benefit when they could afford to pay the full price or something between the fully subsidized and nonsubsidized price.
Concern over Setting Precedents
Concerns may arise that a global subsidy for ACTs sets a precedent for other drugs or health interventions. The main precedent would be to subsidize other antimalarials which international consensus deems should either supplant ACTs or serve as another first-line therapy. If economic conditions in endemic countries are substantially unchanged when that time comes and the new product meets appropriate cost and cost-effectiveness criteria, it would be difficult to exclude it from subsidies.
On the other hand, the possibility that a global subsidy for ACTs would lead to pressure to subsidize drugs for treatment of other diseases should be a lesser concern. A few key factors related to malaria and its treatment, taken together, are unique among the major diseases. These factors are:
Predominance of self-diagnosis and treatment of a life-threatening disease, with private sector drug purchasing, for an unpredictable need at the level of the individual or family
Negligible market for drug in wealthier countries, so minimal opportunity for tiered pricing (particularly because ACTs are not appropriate for prophylaxis for travelers)
Lack of a viable replacement for artemisinins as first-line drug
Need for drug change because the historically effective drug has failed rather than extending a new medical benefit (as with the provision of long-term treatment for HIV-infected individuals); the major aim of replacing current antimalarials is to prevent further deterioration of clinical management