Cover Image


View/Hide Left Panel

of phenotypes in domesticated plants and animals. In Chapter 11, Jeffrey Ross-Ibara, Peter Morrell, and Brandon Gaut illustrate modern genetic approaches to dissecting important phenotypes that have evolved under human influence, with special reference to domestic corn. They distinguish top-down genetic approaches (such as QTL mapping) from bottom-up approaches (such as candidate gene assays), and conclude that the latter method, despite some pitfalls, generally holds greater promise for revealing how key phenotypes in crop plants have evolved under domestication from their ancestral wild states.

In Chapter 12, Al Bennett and Richard Lenski address a longstanding question: Is there a necessary cost to adaptation? In other words, does the evolution of a phenotype that is adaptive to a particular environment necessitate deterioration in other traits? If so, what natural selection can achieve via the adaptive process would inevitably be constrained by such fitness trade-offs. To examine this issue empirically, the authors monitored multigeneration selection responses of bacteria (Escherichia coli) to altered temperature regimes. After 2,000 generations of thermal selection, most colonies that showed improved fitness at low temperatures also showed fitness declines at high temperatures, but this was not invariably the case. The fact that exceptions exist indicates that fitness trade-offs are not an inevitable component of the adaptive evolutionary process.

Bacteria such as E. coli are model experimental organisms because they have short generation lengths and are easy to manipulate, but they also have relatively simple phenotypes. Near the other end of the continuum is Homo sapiens, which has many complex phenotypes of special interest but is far less tractable to experimental manipulation. In Chapter 13, Cynthia Beall describes the adaptations to high-altitude hypoxia (oxygen shortage) displayed by humans indigenous to the Andean and Tibetan plateaus. Remarkably, the physiological and molecular adaptations to hypoxia differ dramatically between these two populations, suggesting different evolutionary pathways to the same functional outcome. Beall describes how scientists are currently dissecting the evolutionary genetic responses to oxygen deprivation displayed by these two populations, and in so doing reveals some of the special challenges of working with a nonmodel experimental species.

Beetles (Coleoptera) have long been intriguing to biologists. The British geneticist and evolutionist J.B.S. Haldane famously remarked that the Creator must have had an inordinate fondness for beetles because he made so many species of them (at least half a million). A century earlier, Darwin had speculated that the oft-ornate horns that many beetles carry on their heads or thorax were favored by sexual selection as weapons, used in jousts between males over mating access to females. Darwin’s fascination with beetles began in childhood and grew in his college years,

The National Academies | 500 Fifth St. N.W. | Washington, D.C. 20001
Copyright © National Academy of Sciences. All rights reserved.
Terms of Use and Privacy Statement