. "Appendix D: Comparison of 238Pu to Alternatives." Radioisotope Power Systems: An Imperative for Maintaining U.S. Leadership in Space Exploration. Washington, DC: The National Academies Press, 2009.
The following HTML text is provided to enhance online
readability. Many aspects of typography translate only awkwardly to HTML.
Please use the page image
as the authoritative form to ensure accuracy.
Radioisotope Power Systems: An Imperative for Maintaining U.S. Leadership in Space Exploration
TABLE D.1 Primary Emissions Produced by Radioisotopes with Half-lives of 15 to 100 Years
Isotope
Half-Life (years)
Type of Primary Emissions
Promethium-145 (Pm-145)
18
gamma
Halfnium-178m (Hf-178m)
31
gamma
Bismuth-207 (Bi-207)
33
gamma
Europium-150 (Eu-150)
37
gamma
Titanium-44 (Ti-44)
47
gamma
Platinum-193 (Pt-193)
50
gamma
Terbium-157 (Tb-157)
99
gamma
Actinium-227 (Ac-227)
22
beta, some alpha
Niobium-93m (Nb-93m)
16
beta, gamma
Lead-210 (Pb-210)
22
beta, some alpha
Strontium-90 (Sr-90)
29
beta
Cesium-137 (Cs-137)
30
beta, gamma
Argon-42 (Ar-42)
33
beta
Tin-121m (Sn-121m)
55
beta
Samarium-151 (Sm-151)
90
beta
Nickel-63 (Ni-63)
100
beta
Curium-244 (Cm-244)
18
alpha, spontaneous fission
Curium-243 (Cm-243)
29
alpha, gamma
Uranium-232 (U-232)
72
alpha, spontaneous fission
Gadolinium-148 (Gd-148)
75
alpha
Plutonium-238 (Pu-238)
88
alpha, spontaneous fission
SOURCE: Department of Energy, information memorandum and associated transmittal memorandum to S-1 from NE-1 on the subject of “Alternatives to Plutonium-238 for Space Power Applications,” dated August 4, 1992, Office of Nuclear Energy, Science, and Technology, Washington, D.C., Table 1, updated.
thorium-228) emit a significant level of gamma radiation, resulting in dose rates that are higher than either 244Cm or 238Pu heat sources of comparable size. This leaves 238Pu and 244Cm as the only isotopes worthy of further consideration.3
Table D.2 compares the characteristics of 238Pu and 244Cm. Both produce gamma radiation (although the amount produced is much smaller than the amount from isotopes that produce gamma radiation as a primary emission). As shown, 244Cm produces much more gamma radiation than 238Pu. Also, the fast neutron radiation level from 244Cm is nearly 450 times that of 238Pu. These high gamma and neutron radiation levels would require shielding during handling and use of the 244Cm heat sources to protect personnel and sensitive components. The shield weights would most likely be too heavy for deep-space applications.
Nearly all of the gamma dose from 238Pu is attributable to the decay chain of the 236Pu isotope impurity in the fuel, which is limited to very small amounts by 238Pu fuel quality specifications.
TABLE D.2 Characteristics of 238Pu and 244Cm Isotope Fuels
a Gamma shielding to reduce dose rates to ~5 mR/hr @ 1m (equivalent to Pu-238)
SOURCE: Department of Energy, information memorandum and associated transmittal memorandum to S-1 from NE-1 on the subject of “Alternatives to Plutonium-238 for Space Power Applications,” dated August 4, 1992, Office of Nuclear Energy, Science, and Technology, Washington, D.C., Table 2.
POWER DENSITY/SPECIFIC POWERCONSIDERATIONS
The power density (watts/cubic centimeter) and specific power (watts/gram) of radioisotope fuel is directly proportional to the energy absorbed per disintegration and is inversely proportional to half-life. (As shown in Table D.2, 244Cm has a higher specific power and power density than 238Pu, because the former has a shorter half-life, but the selection of RPSs powered by 238Pu to power many important missions has demonstrated that its specific power and power density are acceptable.) Higher power density leads to smaller volume heat sources for comparable power levels and higher specific power leads to lighter weight heat sources. Both characteristics are highly significant for space power heat sources. For radioisotope fuels with comparable half-lives, a beta emitting heat source will be larger and heavier than an alpha emitter.
FUEL FORM CONSIDERATIONS
The radioisotope fuel must be used in a fuel form that has a high melting point and remains stable during credible launch accidents and accidental reentries into Earth’s atmosphere. The fuel form must also be noncorrosive and chemically compatible with its containment material (metallic cladding) over the operating lifetime of the power system. It is desirable that the fuel form have a low solubility rate in the human body and the natural environment. Daughter products and the decay process must not affect the integrity of the fuel form. All of the alpha emitting isotopes listed in
3
Four additional alpha emitters have half-lives between 100 and 500 years (polonium-209, americium-242m, californium-249, and americium-241). In addition to the problem of low specific power (caused by their long half-life), all four also emit significant amounts of gamma rays.