National Academy of Sciences | 150 Year Anniversary

Questions? Call 800-624-6242

| Items in cart [0]

The National Academies Press

HARDBACK
price:$59.00
add to cart

Rights & Permissions

topleft topright

In the Light of Evolution III: Two Centuries of Darwin (2009)
National Academy of Sciences (NAS)

Citation Manager

. "1 Natural Selection inAction During Speciation--Sara Via." In the Light of Evolution III: Two Centuries of Darwin. Washington, DC: The National Academies Press, 2009.

Please select a format:

BibTeX EndNote RefMan


Page
22
bottomleft bottomright

The following HTML text is provided to enhance online readability. Many aspects of typography translate only awkwardly to HTML. Please use the page image as the authoritative form to ensure accuracy.


In the Light of Evolution Volume III: Two Centuries of Darwin

sequences within regions of divergence hitchhiking can begin to diverge by genetic drift or independent responses to directional and stabilizing selection within each race. The free recombination enjoyed within races can accelerate divergence at these loci by allowing beneficial mutations to spread within races, while divergence hitchhiking blocks their export to the other race. Some allelic substitutions within regions of divergence hitchhiking may produce genetic incompatibilities between the new species. Thus, an additional prediction of this model is that genes for hybrid sterility or inviability that are found close to “branch-defining” QTL will have, on average, a greater time to most recent common ancestor than will those found in other genomic regions.

Stage 2:
Divergence by Genetic Drift and Independent Responses to Directional or Balancing Selection (Fig. 1.6A and B)

By the end of stage 1, most gene exchange is likely to have already been blocked by the ecologically based reproductive isolation that reduces effective migration. The incipient species are now essentially “ecologically allopatric.” Thus begins stage 2, in which the parts of the genome outside regions of divergence hitchhiking begin to differentiate by genetic drift or independent responses to selection within the new lineages. This secondary divergence will eventually bring all of the variation in polymorphic gene trees into widespread phylogenetic concordance with the branching pattern determined earlier by divergent selection on QTL affecting the key ecologically important traits.

Given that only a small fraction of the genome may be affected by divergent selection during stage 1, most of the eventual genetic divergence between new ecological species is likely to occur during stage 2. Genetic analyses of hybrid sterility and inviability reveal that genetic incompatibilities are numerous and scattered throughout the genome (Masly and Presgraves, 2007). It is thus probable that by the end of stage 2, the number of genetic incompatibilities that have accumulated could far outnumber, and potentially obscure, the adaptive genetic changes that were actually involved in the initial evolution of reproductive isolation under divergent selection during stage 1. This is one of the major drawbacks of the exclusive use of the spyglass in the study of speciation genetics.

In many cases of speciation by divergent selection, enough ecologically based reproductive isolation will evolve to isolate a pair of new species before many DMIs can accumulate. Even so, the genetic incompatibilities that lead to hybrid sterility and inviability play a very important role in ecological speciation because they make the ecologically based reproductive isolation that evolved earlier permanent and irreversible. By the end of stage 2, it is likely that enough genetic incompatibilities will

Page
22
Front Matter (R1-R16)
Part I: NATURAL SELECTION, OR ADAPTATION TO NATURE (1-4)
1 Natural Selection inAction During Speciation--Sara Via (5-26)
2 Adaptive Radiations:From Field to Genomic Studies--Scott A. Hodges and Nathan J. Derieg (27-46)
3 Genetics and Ecological Speciation--Dolph Schluter and Gina L. Conte (47-64)
4 Cascades of Convergent Evolution: The Corresponding Evolutionary Histories of Euglenozoans and Dinoflagellates--Julius Lukeš, Brian S. Leander, and Patrick J. Keeling (65-84)
Part II: ARTIFICIAL SELECTION, OR ADAPTATION TO HUMAN DEMANDS (85-88)
5 From Wild Animals to Domestic Pets, an Evolutionary View of Domestication--Carlos A. Driscoll, David W. Macdonald, and Stephen J. O'Brien (89-110)
6 Tracking Footprints of Maize Domestication and Evidence for a Massive Selective Sweep on Chromosome 10--Feng Tian, Natalie M. Stevens, and Edward S. Buckler IV (111-128)
7 Human-Induced Evolution Caused by Unnatural Selection Through Harvest of Wild Animals--Fred W. Allendorf and Jeffrey J. Hard (129-148)
8 In the Light of Directed Evolution: Pathways of Adaptive Protein Evolution--Jesse D. Bloom and Frances H. Arnold (149-164)
Part III: SEXUAL SELECTION, OR ADAPTATION TO MATING DEMANDS (165-168)
9 Mate Choice and Sexual Selection: What Have We Learned Since Darwin?--Adam G. Jones and Nicholas L. Ratterman (169-190)
10 Sexual Selection and Mating Systems--Stephen M. Shuster (191-212)
11 Reproductive Decisions Under Ecological Constraints: It's About Time--Patricia Adair Gowaty and Stephen P. Hubbell (213-242)
12 Postcopulatory Sexual Selection: Darwin's Omission and Its Consequences--William G. Eberhard (243-262)
Part IV: THE DARWINIAN LEGACY, 150 YEARS LATER (263-266)
13 Darwin and the Scientific Method--Francisco J. Ayala (267-286)
14 The Darwinian Revolution: Rethinking Its Meaningand Significance--Michael Ruse (287-306)
15 Did Darwin Write *the Origin* Backwards?--Elliott Sober (307-328)
16 Darwin's Place in the History of Thought: A Reevaluation--Robert J. Richards (329-342)
17 Darwin's "Strange Inversion of Reasoning"--Daniel Dennett (343-354)
References (355-398)
Index (399-414)