Criteria for Assessing Practices Draft Proposed at Workshop to Facilitate Discussion
Program or practice effectiveness—the second element—was more focused on the program or intervention and asked whether it achieved its goals. It is a somewhat narrower construction than the notion of impact.
Replicability focuses on the extent to which a practice is unique to a particular situation or can be used elsewhere. What kind of modifications would be needed to have a program that is successful in one venue be successful in other venues without significant adaptation? A related question is to ask which factors limit or encourage replicability, because that helps one to understand the context in which a practice can work or not.
Sustainability is, in a sense, the other side of replicability and focuses on whether a practice can continue beyond an initial outlay of resources (e.g., initial funding). Individual programs or initiatives are often funded for a set period of time and then financing is reduced or eliminated (sometimes with the idea that other sources of funding will be found by the time the initial period ends). This is very common in almost any