|
Area of Concern
|
Examples of Evidence Needed
|
|
Relevance of the intervention on a large scale
|
|
|
• Generalizability
|
Likelihood of achieving the expected outcomes in different demographic groups and in different communities/regions
|
|
• Sustainability
|
Likelihood that the intervention effect will last more than 1 to 5 years in the various groups
|
|
• Stakeholder acceptance
|
Likelihood that the intervention be well received by the target population/community and program delivery personnel
|
|
Costs and benefits of large-scale implementation
|
|
|
• Cost-effectiveness
|
Costs of the intervention versus measured effects on the outcomes of interest (e.g., premature deaths averted, years of life saved, pounds lost) compared with other competitive interventions
|
|
• Cost/benefit
|
Value of health benefits versus the costs of implementation compared with other competitive interventions
|
|
• Cost feasibility
|
Costs of implementing the intervention on a communitywide scale compared with other competitive interventions
|
|
• Cost minimization
|
Costs of implementing the intervention in a hospital compared with costs of implementing a competitive intervention in a community clinic and achieving the same outcome
|
|
• Cost utility
|
Stakeholder preferences versus implementation costs compared with other competitive interventions
|
|
Political and practical concerns
|
|
|
• Implementation priorities
|
Fit of the intervention with community or policy priorities; basis for giving this intervention high priority
|
|
• Portfolio balance
|
Fit within an overall set of interventions if considerations of feasibility, size of impact, and certainty of effect are combined
|
|
• Strategic planning
|
Strategies and tactics that can be used to mount this intervention
|
|
• Potential challenges
|
Implementation challenges that can be anticipated and evidence on how to overcome them
|