7

General Observations

Throughout the workshop, speakers made general observations about the issues associated with critical materials and the role of the chemical sciences in addressing those issues. These observations are gathered in this final chapter to capture the broad themes emerging from the workshop. These themes should not be seen as consensus conclusions of the workshop and are associated here with the speaker who made that observation.

  • The level of criticality for a material depends on many factors, including physical availability, cost, importance in use, supply risk, concentration within a country, coproduction, potential for substitution, and environment and social concerns. (Eggert)
  • The level of criticality for a material can change over time as the factors affecting criticality change. (Eggert)
  • The importance of these factors differs from one material or element to another. (Eggert)
  • Different groups have different definitions of critical materials depending on their needs and circumstances. (Eggert)
  • Markets respond to both supply and demand signals but with time lags. (Eggert)
  • Government has an essential role to play in pushing for undistorted international trade, streamlining regulation, facilitating the collection and dissemination of information, and facilitating research and development. (Eggert)
  • The chemical sciences have an important influence on critical materials through research and development involving substitution, improvements in extraction and recovery, and improvements in manufacturing and recycling. (Eggert)
  • Governmental policies also have a major influence on criticality, including policies on domestic production and processing, stockpiling, education, and diplomacy. (Bauer)
  • Even if the price of a critical material is a small fraction of a catalyst, supply constraints can interfere with that application of the material. (Stevens)
  • Research can reduce or eliminate the use of a critical material in a catalyst and thereby reduce or eliminate the effects of price or supply disruptions. (Chen)
  • Replacing expensive metals with inexpensive metals in catalysts can produce significant savings and be more environmentally benign. (Bullock)
  • Even in long-established applications like automotive catalytic converters, continued research can reduce the demand for precious metals, even where complete replacement of those metals is not yet feasible. (Lambert)
  • Proven reserves of rare earths are growing rapidly, and one solution to tight supplies is to increase mining. (Shinar)
  • Demand for some critical materials will soar if the world acquires a significant fraction of its energy from photovoltaics. (Zweibel)
  • Resources constraints could be a critical factor in the development of grid-scale energy storage technologies. (Bradwell)
  • Issues that need to be considered in establishing critical materials policies include trade restrictions, the extended times needed to develop new technologies, costs, and environmental impacts. (Whitacre)


The National Academies | 500 Fifth St. N.W. | Washington, D.C. 20001
Copyright © National Academy of Sciences. All rights reserved.
Terms of Use and Privacy Statement



Below are the first 10 and last 10 pages of uncorrected machine-read text (when available) of this chapter, followed by the top 30 algorithmically extracted key phrases from the chapter as a whole.
Intended to provide our own search engines and external engines with highly rich, chapter-representative searchable text on the opening pages of each chapter. Because it is UNCORRECTED material, please consider the following text as a useful but insufficient proxy for the authoritative book pages.

Do not use for reproduction, copying, pasting, or reading; exclusively for search engines.

OCR for page 45
7 General Observations Throughout the workshop, speakers made general obser- • Governmental policies also have a major influence on vations about the issues associated with critical materials criticality, including policies on domestic production and the role of the chemical sciences in addressing those and processing, stockpiling, education, and diplomacy. issues. These observations are gathered in this final chapter (Bauer) to capture the broad themes emerging from the workshop. • Even if the price of a critical material is a small fraction These themes should not be seen as consensus conclusions of of a catalyst, supply constraints can interfere with that the workshop and are associated here with the speaker who application of the material. (Stevens) made that observation. • Research can reduce or eliminate the use of a critical material in a catalyst and thereby reduce or eliminate • The level of criticality for a material depends on the effects of price or supply disruptions. (Chen) many factors, including physical availability, cost, • Replacing expensive metals with inexpensive metals in importance in use, supply risk, concentration within a catalysts can produce significant savings and be more country, coproduction, potential for substitution, and environmentally benign. (Bullock) environment and social concerns. (Eggert) • Even in long-established applications like automotive • The level of criticality for a material can change over catalytic converters, continued research can reduce time as the factors affecting criticality change. (Eggert) the demand for precious metals, even where com- • The importance of these factors differs from one mate- plete replacement of those metals is not yet feasible. rial or element to another. (Eggert) (Lambert) • Different groups have different definitions of critical • Proven reserves of rare earths are growing rapidly, and materials depending on their needs and circumstances. one solution to tight supplies is to increase mining. (Eggert) (Shinar) • Markets respond to both supply and demand signals • Demand for some critical materials will soar if the but with time lags. (Eggert) world acquires a significant fraction of its energy from • Government has an essential role to play in pushing photovoltaics. (Zweibel) for undistorted international trade, streamlining regu- • Resources constraints could be a critical factor in the lation, facilitating the collection and dissemination of development of grid-scale energy storage technolo- information, and facilitating research and develop- gies. (Bradwell) ment. (Eggert) • Issues that need to be considered in establishing • The chemical sciences have an important influence on critical materials policies include trade restrictions, the critical materials through research and development extended times needed to develop new technologies, involving substitution, improvements in extraction costs, and environmental impacts. (Whitacre) and recovery, and improvements in manufacturing and recycling. (Eggert) 45

OCR for page 45