A

Convocation Agenda

Thinking Evolutionarily:
Evolution Education Across the Life Sciences
Organized by:
Board on Life Sciences, National Research Council
National Academy of Sciences
Co-hosted by Carnegie Institution for Science
1530 P St., NW, Washington, DC
October 25-26, 2011

 

We sincerely thank the National Academy of Sciences, the Burroughs-Wellcome Fund, the Christian A. Johnson Endeavor Foundation, the Carnegie Institution for Science, and the National Science Foundation through a Research Coordination Network/Undergraduate Biology Education grant to the University of Oklahoma for their generous support of this convocation.

DAY 1: EXPLORING THE OPPORTUNITIES AND
SETTING THE STAGE FOR FUTURE ACTION

Tuesday, October 25

11:15 AM

Registration, First Floor Foyer Lunch

Available beginning at 11:30, Rotunda (2nd floor)

12:00 PM Auditorium

Welcome and Introductions

- Jay Labov, National Research Council and National Academy of Sciences

- Maxine Singer, President Emerita, Carnegie Institution for Science



The National Academies | 500 Fifth St. N.W. | Washington, D.C. 20001
Copyright © National Academy of Sciences. All rights reserved.
Terms of Use and Privacy Statement



Below are the first 10 and last 10 pages of uncorrected machine-read text (when available) of this chapter, followed by the top 30 algorithmically extracted key phrases from the chapter as a whole.
Intended to provide our own search engines and external engines with highly rich, chapter-representative searchable text on the opening pages of each chapter. Because it is UNCORRECTED material, please consider the following text as a useful but insufficient proxy for the authoritative book pages.

Do not use for reproduction, copying, pasting, or reading; exclusively for search engines.

OCR for page 69
A Convocation Agenda Thinking Evolutionarily: Evolution Education Across the Life Sciences Organized by: Board on Life Sciences, National Research Council National Academy of Sciences Co-hosted by Carnegie Institution for Science 1530 P St., NW, Washington, DC October 25-26, 2011 We sincerely thank the National Academy of Sciences, the Burroughs- Wellcome Fund, the Christian A. Johnson Endeavor Foundation, the Carnegie Institution for Science, and the National Science Foundation through a Research Coordination Network/Undergraduate Biology Edu- cation grant to the University of Oklahoma for their generous support of this convocation. DAY 1: EXPLORING THE OPPORTUNITIES AND SETTING THE STAGE FOR FUTURE ACTION Tuesday, October 25 Registration, First Floor Foyer 11:15 AM Lunch Available beginning at 11:30, Rotunda (2nd floor) 12:00 PM Auditorium Welcome and Introductions - Jay Labov, National Research Council and National Academy of Sciences - Maxine Singer, President Emerita, Carnegie Institution for Science 69

OCR for page 69
70 APPENDIX A - Susan Kassouf, Program Officer, Christian A. Johnson Endeavor Foundation (sponsor) - Cynthia Beall, Chair of the Convocation’s Organizing Committee and Moderator 12:15 PM Auditorium The Case for Thinking Evolutionarily Across the Life Sciences - Introductory Undergraduate Biology Courses: Gordon Uno, University of Oklahoma and PI for the NSF’s Research Coordination Network for Undergraduate Biology Education (special advisor to the Committee and PI of the NSF/RCN-UBE grant that is sponsoring this convocation). - Judy Scotchmoor, Museum of Paleontology, University of California, Berkeley Questions and Discussion 1:15 PM Auditorium Can This Approach Improve Student Learning of Evolution? The Evidence Base - Ross Nehm, Ohio State University Questions and Discussion 2:00 PM Rotunda Break and opportunity for further networking 2:15 PM Auditorium Expanding Curricular Opportunities to Introduce Evolutionary Thinking Across the Grade Spans— Brief Presentations and Panel Discussion - Spencer Benson, University of Maryland: The Role of Evolution in the Restructured Advanced Placement Biology Course

OCR for page 69
71 APPENDIX A - Celeste Carter, National Science Foundation: Vision and Change in Undergraduate Education - William Galey, Howard Hughes Medical Institute: Scientific Foundations for Future Physicians - Kristin Jenkins, National Evolutionary Synthesis Center and Member of the Organizing Committee: NESCENT Programs Promoting Evolutionary Thinking - Mark Schwartz, New York University: Evolutionary Medicine in Biology and Pre-Med Courses Discussion and Questions 3:15 PM Auditorium Who Are the Audiences We Are Trying to Reach with this Initiative? - Cynthia Beall, moderator 3:45 PM Auditorium How Can Evolutionary Thinking Help Address the Controversies Surrounding the Teaching of Evolution?: A Faculty Forum - Betty Carvellas, National Academies Teacher Advisory Council - David Hillis, University of Texas, Austin - Paul Strode, Fairview High School (Boulder, CO) - Marlene Zuk, University of California, Riverside 4:30 PM Breakout Rooms First Breakout Sessions: Exploring the Issues In Greater Depth The colored dot on your name badge indicates the breakout session to which you have been assigned. Each of these breakout sessions will contain a mix of people with different kinds of expertise. The goal of each

OCR for page 69
72 APPENDIX A session will be to explore in depth one of the issues raised in earlier sessions and report back ideas for next steps to all participants. Each group will be facilitated by a member of the organizing committee. Each group will appoint one person to present an overview of the group’s ideas and suggestions at the end of the morning. Each group will decide when to call a break. Group 1 (yellow dot, Ballroom): What constitutes evolutionary thinking? What approaches are needed to educate faculty and departments about the value of evolutionary thinking in their own courses and programs? Facilitated by Nancy Moran, Yale University Group 2 (blue dot, Board Room): What additional evidence is needed to convince biologists of the value of evolutionary thinking? How can that evidence best be gathered through an organized program of research? Who should undertake and sponsor such research? Facilitated by Ida Chow, Society for Developmental Biology, and Paul Beardsley, California Polytechnic University Group 3 (green dot, Mayor Room): How can evolutionary thinking become more firmly connected with other emerging efforts to improve life sciences education? In what ways should these efforts be influenced by different target audiences? Facilitated by Gordon Uno, University of Oklahoma, and Kristin Jenkins, National Evolutionary Synthesis Center 5:30 PM Auditorium Reports from Breakout Groups (10 minutes each plus discussion) 6:15 PM Auditorium Closing Remarks, Announcements, and Charge for Day 2 - Cynthia Beall

OCR for page 69
73 APPENDIX A 6:30 PM Auditorium Adjourn for the Day Evening Dinner on Your Own for Participants (see accompanying list of suggested restaurants in the Dupont Circle area) DAY 2: PLANNING FOR FUTURE ACTIONS TO INFUSE EVOLUTIONARY THINKING ACROSS LIFE SCIENCES EDUCATION Wednesday, October 26 7:30 AM Breakfast Available in the Rotunda 8:00 AM Auditorium Synthesis, Reflections on Day 1 and on Moving Forward - Robert Pennock, BEACON Center for the Study of Evolution in Action, Michigan State University 8:45 AM Auditorium Reactions and Further Discussion - Panel of Committee Members- Open microphone for participants 9:15 AM Auditorium Expanding Resources for Teaching Evolutionary Thinking - Paul Beardsley (member of the organizing committee), California Polytechnic Institute - Joseph Levine, Pearson Education and Co-Author (with Kenneth Miller) of Biology - Judy Scotchmoor, Director, Understanding Evolution and Understanding Science Websites, Museum of Paleontology, University of California, Berkeley

OCR for page 69
74 APPENDIX A - John Jungck (Beloit College, BioQuest) Discussion and Questions 10:00 AM Auditorium Moderated Panel Discussion: Next Steps: Potential Roles of Key Players - James Collins (Arizona State University and member of the organizing committee), President of American Institute of Biological Sciences - Jaclyn Reeves-Pepin, Executive Director, National Association of Biology Teachers - Joseph LaManna, President, Federation of American Societies for Experimental Biology - Amy Chang, Director of Education Programs, American Society for Microbiology 10:30 AM Rotunda Break and opportunity for further networking 11:00 AM Auditorium Moving Evolution Education Forward: Why Evolution and Evolutionary Thinking Are Integral Components of Molecular Biology of the Cell - Bruce Alberts, University of California San Francisco, Editor-in-Chief, Science Questions and Discussion 12:00 PM Second Breakout Sessions: Moving from Vision to Breakout Action (Working Lunch) These sessions are designed to have people with Rooms – similar interests and expertise meet with each other Lunch is to craft action items that can be carried forward. Your available in group should: develop up to three action items that can the Rotunda be undertaken by colleagues in the sector your group represents in the next six months; discuss how your action items might connect with at least one of the other

OCR for page 69
75 APPENDIX A sectors represented in breakout groups; and discuss how the National Research Council and National Academy of Sciences might assist your efforts. Group 1 (Board Room): Faculty who teach courses in biology and evolution. Facilitated by Irene Eckstrand, National Institutes of Health, and Nancy Moran, Yale University Group 2 (Mayor Room): Funders of programs in life sciences education. Facilitated by James Collins, Arizona State University, and Kristin Jenkins, National Evolutionary Synthesis Center Group 3 (Ballroom): Representatives from Professional Societies. Facilitated by Ida Chow, Society for Developmental Biology Group 4 (Auditorium): Curriculum Developers and Education Researchers. Facilitated by Gordon Uno, University of Oklahoma, and Paul Beardsley, California Polytechnic Institute. 1:30 PM Reports from Breakout Groups (10 minutes each plus discussion) 2:30 PM Closing Thoughts and Reflections - Members of the Organizing Committee, Other Participants 3:00 PM Adjourn

OCR for page 69