Cover Image

Not for Sale



View/Hide Left Panel
Click for next page ( 17


The National Academies | 500 Fifth St. N.W. | Washington, D.C. 20001
Copyright © National Academy of Sciences. All rights reserved.
Terms of Use and Privacy Statement



Below are the first 10 and last 10 pages of uncorrected machine-read text (when available) of this chapter, followed by the top 30 algorithmically extracted key phrases from the chapter as a whole.
Intended to provide our own search engines and external engines with highly rich, chapter-representative searchable text on the opening pages of each chapter. Because it is UNCORRECTED material, please consider the following text as a useful but insufficient proxy for the authoritative book pages.

Do not use for reproduction, copying, pasting, or reading; exclusively for search engines.

OCR for page 16
4 I N N O VAT I O N S I N T R AV E L D E M A N D M O D E L I N G , V O L U M E 1 aggregate analysis has been resolved, with general agree- expect from the modeling community. I would like you ment on the use of disaggregate analysis. Advances in dis- to write down four items to remember: (a) what you do crete choice modeling include the use of multinomial and is very important; (b) things are changing very rapidly; nested logit models, generalized extreme value models, (c) things are changing faster than our ability to respond; and mixed logit models. These models better represent and (d) under certain circumstances, we need to change complex choices and substitutions among those choices. the foundation of the way we do our jobs. Addressing computation-related issues has been Figure 4 highlights the role of MPOs in the trans- helped by the development of enhanced algorithms for portation decision-making process. I think Keith Lawton many aspects of transportation analysis. The adoption and others in the Portland area deserve a great deal of of microsimulation in travel prediction and in transport credit and thanks for the work they have done on testing systems operations has also been a major improvement. activity-based models and other applications. I think all Enhanced data collection and processing has enhanced MPOs have an obligation to the modeling community-- analysis techniques for control purposes. not just as users of models, but also as developers and There have been significant advancements in land use testers of models. modeling. We have also seen improvements in our abil- MPOs receive guidance from the U.S. Department of ity to represent spatial detail and realistic land market Transportation, citizens, local jurisdictions, and policy representation. There has been increased application of makers. Many MPOs are involved in sharing experiences geographic information systems (GIS) in transport sys- with different models and applications. Within Texas, tem components, trans-shipment terminals, and land use we have partnerships to help integrate models across the components. state. I think MPOs should be more involved in collabo- Dynamic assignment is one of the most central issues rative research and we should be encouraging more part- related to transportation service representation. How- nerships with the private sector and with universities. We ever, to be effective, such analysis must be informed by a all have an obligation to increase communication, and good time-of-day representation of demand. Other issues by increasing communication we can help advance the include spatial detail, consistency across levels of detail, state of the practice, the state of the art, and the decision- refinement of travel supply functions, and enhanced making process. operational control. Models are not an end to themselves. Travel models Despite the tremendous progress that has been made, are a tool to help in the decision-making process. I think we continue to need an increased understanding of behav- we are on the verge of a new foundation in travel mod- ioral responses. Both modelers and policy makers need to els. Too often in the past, the information system and the understand why we sometimes get unintended conse- model system have been the same. We often have a prob- quences from decisions that seem wise based on travel lem with the public and policy makers confusing the forecasts. We also need a better ability to focus on small steps in the transportation planning process and the steps areas or population groups, as well as the ability to rep- in the modeling process. resent more complex behaviors in models. As we learn Figure 5 illustrates the role that travel models play in more about what we know and what we do not know, the implementation process. I think there has to be a the limitations of existing models become more obvious. broader information system that creates a foundation Other issues that need to be addressed include for the whole transportation planning process. Travel improved presentation of all the aspects of transportation models then become part of this broader foundation. and activity-based analysis, including supply, demand, Travel models, land use models, goods movement mod- and land use. One of the core issues is the need for better els, and inputoutput models are all needed. communication between modelers and decision makers. As Frank Koppelman noted, I think one shortcoming Modelers need a fuller understanding of policy issues and is that we do not spend enough time interpreting the to improve the presentation of modeled impacts to policy model results. The goal of travel models is not to forecast makers. Modelers and decision makers also need to the exact number of vehicles that will use a collector expand the range of decision options to be examined. street in 2010. The goal is to interpret what that number means. One important issue is the different scales for fore- STATE AND LOCAL AGENCY PERSPECTIVES ON casting tools and the need for consistency. We need a POLICY ISSUES: ONE SIZE DOES NOT FIT ALL strong national transportation system that includes national transportation data sets. The national data need Michael Morris to be integrated into statewide data sets. Within Texas, new intercity corridors, called the Trans-Texas Corri- This is a very critical conference at a very critical time. dors, are being developed. Tools are needed to assess My remarks focus on what state and local officials travel in these corridors that are consistent with those