Click for next page ( 22


The National Academies | 500 Fifth St. N.W. | Washington, D.C. 20001
Copyright © National Academy of Sciences. All rights reserved.
Terms of Use and Privacy Statement



Below are the first 10 and last 10 pages of uncorrected machine-read text (when available) of this chapter, followed by the top 30 algorithmically extracted key phrases from the chapter as a whole.
Intended to provide our own search engines and external engines with highly rich, chapter-representative searchable text on the opening pages of each chapter. Because it is UNCORRECTED material, please consider the following text as a useful but insufficient proxy for the authoritative book pages.

Do not use for reproduction, copying, pasting, or reading; exclusively for search engines.

OCR for page 21
21 No TABLE 8 DAYS ALLOWED TO SUBMIT DBE Response COMMITMENTS 14% Increased No. of 28% Declined Allowance for DBE Submission STAs 8% Responsive Bid Requirement (0 days) 11 Responsible Bid 1-day submission 1 2-day submission 1 3-day submission 4 Same 4-day submission 1 50% 5-day submission 2 7-day submission 4 FIGURE 5 Percentage of DBE 10-day submission 4 firms submitting bids as prime 14-day submission 2 contractors in 2002. 15-day submission 2 Reasonable Amount of Time 1 Responsibility with No Time 2 Indicated Copies of solicitations and advertisements used to gain No Response to Question 1 DBE participation. Table 9 summarizes good faith effort submissions and 2. A good faith effort is 80% of the average of the per- acceptances reported in the study survey for 2002 data. The centages of the DBE commitments submitted by all time required to perform a good faith effort will in most cases bidders. delay a decision on the low bidder award and, if the docu- 3. Contractors with a history of using DBEs in the previ- mentation and analysis is difficult, the process could delay ous fiscal years will be assumed to have made a good processing the contract for the actual award. Of the good faith effort to achieve the project goal. faith effort submissions reported in 2002, 640 (77%) were 4. Contractors who have not met any of the previous three accepted. On average, the STAs allow 18 days for determi- administrative reconsiderations may request an admin- nation of good faith effort, with the range from 3 to 45 days. istrative reconsideration of their good faith efforts. California has a worksheet to evaluate good faith efforts. The IOWA EXPEDITED GOOD FAITH EFFORT PROCESS contents are provided in Appendix F. Iowa has adopted a different viewpoint to expedite the good MINIMUM LEVEL OF SELF-PERFORMED WORK faith effort determination. A brief outline of the Iowa deci- sion process is provided here, with details of the 80% good The subcontracting opportunities for DBE or non-DBE sub- faith effort and other elements provided in Appendix F. If a contractors are somewhat defined by either STA or U.S.DOT goal has been established for a contract, the Iowa STA will requirements for a specified percentage of work performed by award the contract to the lowest bidder making good faith the prime contractor's workforce that is commonly termed efforts to meet the contract goal. The following is a synopsis of the Iowa process: "self-performed" work. Contracts with federal aid usually require that the prime contractor has the responsibility to per- 1. Bidders with 80% of the established goal will be form at least 30% of the work. This would suggest that 70% assumed to have made a good faith effort. of the contract would be available for subcontracting. How- ever, availability also depends a great deal on contract pack- aging. Some STAs specifically elect to package contract work No according to a work type, such as excavation, paving, and Response Increased structures like box culverts, which limits subcontracting oppor- 17% tunity availability. Where the contractor is required to perform 19% 50% of the contract work, the opportunities for subcontracting Declined may be restricted. Table 10 shows the distribution of self- 8% performed work required by the responding STAs. Same FINANCIAL INCENTIVES FOR DISADVANTAGED 56% BUSINESS ENTERPRISE USE FIGURE 6 Percentage of DBE firms submitting Eleven of the 36 respondents reported that they had some form competitive subcontract bids of incentive for improving DBE use. None were geared toward in 2002. giving direct financial incentive. Most of the respondents, like