Impact of Airport Pavement Deicing Products on Aircraft and Airfield Infrastructure (2008)

Below is the uncorrected machine-read text of this chapter, intended to provide our own search engines and external engines with highly rich, chapter-representative searchable text of each book. Because it is UNCORRECTED material, please consider the following text as a useful but insufficient proxy for the authoritative book pages.

39 REFERENCES ACI Committee 302, Guide for Concrete Floor and Slab Construction, ACI 302.1R-96, American Concrete Insti- tute, Farmington Hills, Mich., 1996. Advanced Asphalt Technologies, LLC, Phase II Plans with Summary of Phase I Results, Airfield Asphalt Pavement Technology Program Project 05-03: Effect of Deicing Chemicals on HMA Airfield Pavements, Interim Report, May 2, 2007. Aerodrome Standards Department, Effect of Corrosive Ma- terials on Aeronautical Ground Lighting, United Kingdom Civil Aviation Authority, Notice to Aerodrome License Holders, July 2004. “Airport Winter Safety and Operations,” Advisory Circular No. 150/5200-30B, draft, Federal Aviation Administra- tion, Washington, D.C., n.d. “Airworthiness Directives; Boeing Model B737-600, -700, -700C, -800, and -900 Series Airplanes,” Federal Aviation Administration, Washington, D.C., Sep. 14, 2005. Alatyppö, V., Conclusions—Finnish Deicing Project, Helsinki University of Technology, Laboratory of Highway Engi- neering, Helsinki, Finland, 2005. Alatyppö, V. and J. Valtonen, “Experiences on the Effects of De-Icing Chemicals on Bituminous Airfield Runways in Finland,” Proceedings of the 2007 FAA Worldwide Air- port Technology Transfer Conference, Atlantic City, N.J., Apr. 16–18, 2007. Al-Otoom, A., A. Al-Khaifa, and A. Shawaqfeh, “Crystal- lization Technology for Reducing Water Permeability into Concrete,” Industrial and Engineering Chemistry Re- search, Vol. 46, No. 16, 2007, pp. 5463–5467. Ambrose, M., “Icing Experts Concerned by EASA Pro- posal,” Journal of the European Regions Airline Associa- tion, July 2007, p. 9. Badawy, W.A., F.M. Al-Kharafi, and E.Y. Al-Hassan, “The Electrochemical Behavior of Cadmium in Aqueous Solu- tions: EIS Investigation,” Materials Science Forum, 289–292 (Pt. 2), 1998, pp. 849–859. Badawy, W.A. and F.M. Al-Kharafi, “A Review on the Cor- rosion and Corrosion Inhibition of Cadmium in Aqueous Solutions,” Current Topics in Electrochemistry, No. 6, 1998, pp. 33–73. Badawy, W.A. and F.M. Al-Kharafi, “Inhibition of Corrosion of Cadmium in Alkaline Solutions,” Bulletin of Electro- chemistry, Vol. 16, No. 4, 2000, pp. 155–160. Baldwin, K.R. and C.J.E. Smith, “Advances in Replacements for Cadmium Plating in Aerospace Applications,” Trans- actions of the Institute of Metal Finishing, Vol. 74, No. 6, 1996, pp. 202–209. Barett, M.L. and J.G. Pigman, “Evaluation of Automated Bridge Deck Anti-Icing System,” Research Report KTC 01-26/KH 36-97-1F, Dec. 2001, p. 18. Berglund, K., et al., U.S. Patent 6287480 B1, “Deicing Com- positions and Methods of Use,” Sep. 2001. Berglund, K., et al., U.S. Patent 6623657 B1, “Water Acti- vated Exothermic Chemical Deicing Formulations,” Sep. 2003. Boeing, Evaluation of Airplane Maintenance Materials, Boeing Document 487617 Revision P., Seattle, Wash., 2003. Brough, L.A., “Corrosion of Packaged Cadmium-Plated Electrical Control Units from Paint Vapors,” Materials Performance, Vol. 26, No. 8, 1987, pp. 32–33. Carabineiro, S.A., I.F. Silva, M. Klimkiewicz, and S. Eser, “In-situ Techniques for Studying Deterioration of C/C Composite Aircraft Brakes by Catalytic Oxidation,” Ma- terials and Corrosion, Vol. 50, No. 12, 1999, pp. 689–695. Chai, S. and W. Mason, Landing Gear Integration in Aircraft Conceptual Design, Virginia Polytechnic and State Univer- sity, Blacksburg, 1996, pp. 35–36 [Online] Available: www. aoe.vt.edu/∼mason/Mason_F/M96SC04.pdf [accessed Apr. 20, 2007]. Claverie, S. and J.P. Chaix, “Compatibility Between Cad- mium and Zinc-Nickel Deposits,” European Coatings, 2007, Vol. 83, No. 6, pp. 33–40. Cody, R.D., A.M. Cody, P.G. Spry, and G. Gan, “Experi- mental Deterioration of Highway Concrete by Chloride Deicing Salts,” Environmental and Engineering Geo- science, Vol. II, No. 4, Winter 1996. Comfort, G., Runway De-Icing Chemicals, Aerodrome Safety Branch, Transport Canada, Ottawa, ON, Canada, Oct. 2000. “Company History,” Dunlop Aerospace Braking Systems, Coventry, U.K. [Online]. Available: www.dunlop-aerospace. com/history_noflash.html [accessed Apr. 20, 2007]. Concurrent Technologies Corporation, Testing Alternative Aircraft and Runway/Taxiway De-icers—Phase II, GSA Test Report CDRL AO12, Johnstown, Pa., June 2004. Cryotech Deicing Technology [Online]. Available: http:// www.cryotech.com/products/CMA40/concrete.php [accessed July 1, 2007]. Deltombe, E., M. Pourbaix, and N. De Zoubov, Atlas of Electrochemical Equilibria in Aqueous Solutions, M. Pourbaix, Ed., Pergamon, London, 1966, 414 pp. Duncan, E., Aircraft Problems from Modern Runway De- icers (Fluids and Pelletized), Presented at the SAE G-12 Committee, May 2006. Duncan, E., Damage from Modern Runway De-Icers (Fluid & Pelletized), Selected Document References, Continental Airlines Engineering, Houston, Tex., June 2007. “Engineering Brief No. 70: Accelerated Alkali-Silica Re- activity in Portland Cement Concrete Pavements Exposed to Runway Deicing Chemicals,” Federal Aviation Admin- istration, Washington, D.C., Dec. 13, 2005. Engineering Technical Letter 06-2: Alkali-Aggregate Re- action in Portland Cement Concrete (PCC) Airfield Pave- ments, Air Force, Virginia, Feb. 9, 2006.

“FAA-Approved Deicing Program Updates, Winter 2006– 2007,” Federal Aviation Administration, Washington, D.C. [Online] Available: http://www.faa.gov/library/manuals/ examiners%5Finspectors/8000/ [accessed July 1, 2007]. Farha, M.H., Y. Hassan, A.O. Abd El Halim, A.G. Razaqpur, A. El-Desouky, and A. Mostafa, “Effects of New Deicing Alternatives on Airfield Asphalt Concrete Pavements,” Pro- ceedings of the 2002 Federal Aviation Administration Tech- nology Transfer Conference, Atlantic City, N.J., May 5–8, 2002. Fay, L., K. Volkening, C. Gallaway, and X. Shi, Perfor- mance and Impacts of Current Deicing and Anti-Icing Products: User Perspective versus Experimental Data, Paper 08-1382, Presented at the 87th Annual Meeting of Transportation Research Board, Washington D.C., Jan. 13–17, 2008. Filip, P., Runway Deicer Assisted Catalytic Oxidation of C/C Aircraft Brakes, Presented to the SAE G-12F Catalytic Oxidation Working Group, San Diego, Calif., May 2007. Flight Safety Foundation Editorial Staff, “Maintaining Visual Aides Helps to Prevent Runway Incursions,” Airport Oper- ations, Vol. 28, No. 3, May/June 2002, pp. 1–7. Folliard, K.J., M.D.A. Thomas, and K.E. Kurtis, “Guidelines for the Use of Lithium to Mitigate or Prevent ASR,” FHWA Report FHWA-RD-03-047, July 2003, 86 pp. General Accounting Office, Aviation and the Environment: Results from a Survey of the Nation’s 50 Busiest Commer- cial Service Airports, GAO/RCED-00-222, Report to Rep- resentative James L. Oberstar, Committee on Transporta- tion and Infrastructure, U.S. House of Representatives, Aug. 2000. Groupe Meban, “Socomor Aeronautic Finishing Solutions,” Socomor Finishing Technologies, Vannes, France [Online]. Available: www.socomor.com/pages/aero/corrosion/htm [accessed July 1, 2007]. Hänninen, T., Testing of Betaine as a Runway De-icing Agent, Civil Aviation Administration Seminar, Finland, Feb. 2006. Hassan, Y., A.O. Abd El Halim, and A.G. Razaqpur, Labo- ratory Evaluation and Assessment of the Effect of Runway Deicers on the Mechanical Properties of Asphalt Concrete Mixes Subjected to Freeze-Thaw Cycles, Safety and Secu- rity, Civil Aviation, Aerodrome Safety, Technical Evalu- ation Engineering Division, Transport Canada, Ontario, ON, Canada, Mar. 2000. Hassan, Y., A.O. Abd El Halim, and A.G. Razaqpur, Effect of Runway De-icers and Warm Temperature on the Mech- anical and Physical Properties of Hot Mix Asphalt Con- crete, Safety and Security, Civil Aviation, Aerodrome Safety, Technical Evaluation Engineering Division, Trans- port Canada, Ontario, ON, Canada, Apr. 2002a. Hassan, Y., A.O. Abd El Halim, A.G. Razaqpur, W. Bekheet, and M.H. Farha, “Effects of Runway Deicers on Pavement Materials and Mixes: Comparison with Road Salt,” Journal of Transportation Engineering, Vol. 128, No. 4, July/ Aug. 2002b, p. 385. Hille, J., “De-icing and Anti-icing Fluid Residues,” Boeing Aero Magazine, 1st quarter, 2007, pp. 15–21. 40 Hinton, B.R.W. and P.N. Trathen, “The Corrosion of Cad- mium Plated Steel in Aircraft Fuel Environments,” Pro- ceedings—Australasian Corrosion Association, 32nd Paper 32/51, 1999, 10 pp. Hunter, C., Runway De-icing Fluid Cadmium Corrosion Test Results, Report AFRL/MLS 05-084, Air Force Research Laboratory—Materials Integrity Branch, Wright–Patterson Air Force Base, Ohio, Aug. 2005. Hutton, T., Dunlop’s Efforts to Address Catalytic Oxidation, Presented to the SAE G-12F Catalytic Oxidation Working Group, San Diego, Calif., May 2007. Jansen, R., Carbon Brake Oxidation at KLM, Presented to the SAE G-12F Carbon Brake Oxidation Working Group, San Diego, Calif., May 2007. Johnson, C., “I-35W and Mississippi River Bridge Anti- Icing Project: Operational Evaluation Report,” Report No. 2001-22, Office of Metro Maintenance Operations, Minnesota Department of Transportation, St. Paul, July 2001. Kato, H., Y. Tamura, and Y. Hayakawa, “Corrosion Inhibitors for Zinc and Cadmium. II. Inhibitive Effect of Quinoline Derivatives on Cadmium Corrosion,” Denki Kagaku, Vol. 41, No. 2, 1973, pp. 97–101. Krutzsch, B., et al., U.S. Patent 5522905, “Diesel Fuel Con- taining an Additive Which Improves the Combustion of Soot,” June 1996. Lang, R. and J. Pabst, U.S. Patent 4318712, “Catalytic Coal Gasification Process,” Mar. 1982. McCrillis, S., Goodrich Efforts to Address Catalytic Oxida- tion, Presented to the SAE G-12F Catalytic Oxidation Working Group, San Diego, Calif., May 2007. Material Safety Data Sheet, MSDS Number 3129a, Standard Reference Materials Program, National Institute of Stan- dards and Technology, Gaithersburg, Md., May 11, 2006. Maxwell, A.T.L., “Wisconsin Tests a Fixed Anti-Icing Sys- tem,” Public Works, July 1999, pp. 26–30. “Metals as Toxins—Cadmium,” Metals in Health and Disease, College of Medicine and Veterinary Medicine, University of Edinburgh, Scotland, United Kingdom [Online]. Available: www.portfolio.mvm.ed.ac.uk/studentwebs/session2/ group29/cadtox.htm [accessed May 25, 2007]. Moles, J.O., J.L. Maier, K.L. Johnson, and S.D. Royer, U.S. Patent Application No. 10/305934, “Aircraft Runway Deicing Composition,” Nov. 26, 2002. Mussato, B.T., O.K. Gepraegs, and G. Farnden, “Relative Effects of Sodium Chloride and Magnesium Chloride on Reinforced Concrete—The State of Art,” CD-ROM, Pro- ceedings of the 84th Annual Meeting of the Transportation Research Board, Washington, D.C., Jan. 9–13, 2005. National Academy of Engineering, Assembly of Engineering (U.S.), and ebrary, Inc., Improving Aircraft Safety, National Academies Press, Washington, D.C., 1980, 131 pp. “New Anti-icing System Planned for Interstate 35E Lexing- ton Bridge Spanning the Mississippi River in St. Paul,” Press Release, Minnesota Department of Transportation, St. Paul, June 30, 2005.

41 Nicholas, M., SAE Cadmium Corrosion Working Group Update (Round Robin Test Results), Presentation to the SAE Cadmium Corrosion Working Group, San Diego, Calif., May 2007. Nilsson, F., “Durability Problems on Nordic Airfields—The Influence of Deicing Agents on Asphalt Concrete,” Pro- ceedings of the XXIInd PIARC World Road Congress, Durban, South Africa, Oct. 19–25, 2003. Nilsson, F., Runway Deicers in Sweden, Presented at the Sem- inar on the Effects of De-Icing Chemicals on Asphalt, Helsinki, Finland, Mar. 14, 2006. Pan, T., L. Fay, and X. Shi, Deicer Impacts on Pavement Materials: A Critical Review, Prepared for the Colorado Department of Transportation, Denver, Dec. 2006. Pan, T., X. He, and X. Shi, “Laboratory Investigation of Acetate-Based Deicing/Anti-icing Agents Deteriorating Airfield Asphalt Concrete,” Paper # 08-13, Submitted to the 83rd Annual Meeting of the Association of Asphalt Paving Technologist (AAPT), Philadelphia, Pa., 2008. Penszynska-Bialczyk, K., K.B. Anderson, T. Szmanski, M. Krkoska, and P. Filip, “Thermal Analysis of Bulk Carbon–Carbon Composite and Friction Products Derived from It During Simulated Aircraft Braking,” Carbon, Vol. 45, 2007, pp. 524–530. Pinet, M., T. Comfort, and M. Griff, “Anti-Icing of Structures Using Fixed Automated Spraying Technology (FAST),” Ministry of Transport, Ontario, Canada, July 2005. Pisano, P., “Automated Anti-Icing Systems Show Potential as Solution to Slippery Streets,” FHWA R&T Transporter, Nov./Dec. 2004. Posselt, H.S. and W.J. Weber, Jr., “Aqueous Corrosion Chem- istry of Cadmium,” In Aqueous-Environmental Chemistry of Metals, A.J. Rubin, Ed., 1974, pp. 291–315. Pro-Act Fact Sheet: Air Force Aircraft and Airfield Deicing/ Anti-icing, Air Force, Virginia, May 1998, 8 pp. Potomac Construction Industries, [Online]. Available: http:// www.pci-potomac.com/faq/scaling.jpg [July 1, 2007]. Rangaraju, P.R., Mitigation of ASR in Presence of Pave- ment Deicing Chemicals, IPRF-01-G-002-04-8, Inno- vative Pavement Research Foundation Airport Concrete Pavement Technology Program, Skokie, Ill., Apr. 2007. Rangaraju, P.R. and J. Desai, “Effectiveness of Selected SCMs in Mitigating ASR in Presence of Potassium Acetate Deicer Solution,” Presented at the 85th Annual Meeting of the Transportation Research Board, Washington, D.C., Jan. 22–26, 2006. Rangaraju, P.R., K.R. Sompura, J. Olek, S. Diamond, and J. Lovell, “Potential for Development of Alkali-Silica Re- action in Presence of Airfield Deicing Chemicals,” Pro- ceedings of the 8th International Conference on Concrete Pavements, Colorado Springs, Colo., Aug. 14–18, 2005. Rangaraju, P.R., K.R. Sompura, and J. Olek, Investigation into Potential of Alkali-Acetate Based Deicers in Causing Alkali-Silica Reaction in Concrete, Presented at the 85th Annual Meeting of the Transportation Research Board, Washington, D.C., Jan. 22–26, 2006. Rangaraju, P.R. and J. Olek, Potential for Acceleration of ASR in the Presence of Pavement Deicing Chemicals, IPFR-01- G-002-03-9, Innovative Pavement Research Foundation Airport Concrete Pavement Technology Program, Skokie, Ill., Mar. 2007. Roosevelt, D.S., “A Bridge-Deck Anti-Icing System in Vir- ginia: Lessons Learned from Pilot Study,” Final Report, VTRC 04-R26, Virginia Transportation Research Coun- cil, Charlottesville, June 2004, 30 pp. Ross, F., Influence of Non-Glycol Runway De-icers on Thick- ened Fluid Dryout, Presented to the SAE G-12 Residues Working Group, San Diego, Calif., 2006. “Runway Deicing Fluid-Electronic Materials Compatibility,” U.S. Airforce Research Laboratory, Wright-Paterson Air Force Base, Ohio, July 2007. SAE A-5A Manufacturers Working Group on Carbon Oxida- tion, “Oxidation Test Method for AO Treated Coupons— Development Details,” SAE Committee Meeting, San Diego, Calif., May 9, 2007. Sava, X., Carbon Brakes Corrosion, Presented to the SAE G-12F Working Group, San Diego, May 14–15, 2007. Seminar on the Effects of De-Icing Chemicals on Asphalt, Helsinki, Finland, Mar. 14, 2006. Seo, J., U.S. Patent 7063803, “Composition for Non-Chloride Based and Less Corrosive Type Liquid Deicer,” June 2006. Shi, X., Table of Commercially Available Anti-icing and Deicing Products, Delivered to the Colorado Department of Transportation, Denver, July 2007. Simola, S., State of the Art and Latest Experiences from the Area of De-icing Fluids, Civil Aviation Administration Seminar, Finland, Mar. 2006. Smith, C., Investigation of Nickel-Cadmium Diffused and Cadmium Plating Replacement Coatings, SAE Technical Paper 920943, 28th Annual Aerospace/Airline Plating and Metal Finishing Forum and Exposition, San Diego, Calif., Apr. 1992. “Specification for Airport Light Bases, Transformer Hous- ings, Junction Boxes, and Accessories,” Advisory Circu- lar No. 150/5345-42F, Federal Aviation Administration, Washington, D.C., Oct. 17, 2006. Stover, E., U.S. Patent 5759622, “Method of Inhibiting Cat- alyzed Oxidation of Carbon–Carbon Composites,” June 1998. Stover, E., U.S. Patent 6551709 B1, “Methods of Inhibiting Catalyzed Oxidation of Carbon–Carbon Composites Using Phosphoric Acid, a Zinc Salt, and an Aluminum Salt and Articles Made Therefrom,” Apr. 2003. Stover, E. and R. Dietz, U.S. Patent 5401440, “Inhibition of Catalyzed Oxidation of Carbon/Carbon Composites,” Mar. 1995. Strassler, E., Airport Deicing Effluent Guidelines Project Update, Presented at the 15th Annual Aircraft and Airfield Deicing and Stormwater Conference, Alexandria, Va., Aug. 6–8, 2006. “Synthesis of Best Practices—Road Salt Management,” Trans- portation Association of Canada, Ottawa, ON, Canada,

2003 [Online]. Available: http://www.tac-atc.ca/english/ pdf/pavement.PDF [accessed Dec. 1, 2006]. Tomlinson, W.J. and N. Wardle, “Electrochemical Equilibria of Cadmium and Water and the Dissolution of Cadmium as a Function of pH,” Corrosion Science, Vol. 15, No. 10, 1975, pp. 663–665. Thomson, M., “Zinc Alloys—The Boeing Alternative to Cadmium,” Transactions of the Institute of Metal Finish- ing, Vol. 74, 1996, pp. 3–5. Transport Canada, “Cancellation of Aerodrome Safety Cir- cular 2002-015, De-icing Fluids Containing Potassium Formate, Dated 2002/04/12,” Aug. 26, 2004. Valtonen, J., JÄPÄ: The Finnish De-icing Project, Presented at the Seminar on the Effects of De-Icing Chemicals on Asphalt, Helsinki, Finland, Mar. 14, 2006. Van Dam, T.J., K.R. Peterson, K.D. Smith, L.L. Sutter, D.G. Peshkin, and R.G. Alger, Design and Construction of Concrete Pavement for Aircraft De-Icing Facilities, IPRF-01-G-002-03-3, Innovative Pavement Research Foundation Airport Concrete Pavement Technology Pro- gram, Skokie, Ill., Apr. 2006. Van Dam, T.J., L.L. Sutter, K.D. Smith, M.J. Wade, and K.R. Peterson, Guidelines for Detection, Analysis, and Treat- ment of Materials-Related Distress in Concrete Pave- ments—Volume 2: Guidelines Description and Use, FHWA-RD-01-164, Turner–Fairbank Highway Research Center, Federal Highway Administration, McLean, Va., Mar. 2002, 233 pp. [Online]. Available: http://www.tfhrc. gov/pavement/pccp/pubs/01164/index.htm [accessed May 1, 2007]. Veeraraghavan, B., S. Prabu, B. Haran, and B. Popov, “Zn-Ni-P Deposits as a Replacement for Cadmium Coat- ings,” Proceedings—Electrochemical Society (2003), 2002-27 (Magnetic Materials, Processes, and Devices VII and Electrodeposition of Alloys), pp. 601–614. Walker, P.L., Jr., M. Shelef, and R.A. Anderson, In Chemistry and Physics of Carbon, P.L. Walker, Jr., Ed., Vol. 4, Mar- cel Dekker, New York, N.Y., 1968, pp. 287–383. Walker, T., Honeywell Efforts to Address Catalytic Oxida- tion, Presented to the SAE G-12 F Catalytic Oxidation Working Group, San Diego, Calif., May 2007. 42 Walker, T.B., et al., “Catalytic Oxidation of Carbon/Carbon Composite Friction Materials,” 23rd International Confer- ence on Carbon, 1997 (abstr.). Walker, T.B. and L. Booker, “Inhibition of Catalytic Oxida- tion in Carbon–Carbon Composite Friction Materials,” Presented to the 1st World Conference on Carbon, Berlin, Germany, 2000. Webb, T., Aircraft Braking Systems Corporation—Catalytic Oxidation Discussion, Presented to the SAE G-12F Car- bon Brake Oxidation Working Group, San Diego, Calif., May 2007. Weyandt, R. and R. Schweisfurth, “Microbiology of Hydraulic Fluids. Part II: Microbial Effects on Corrosion in HFA Liq- uids and Effects of Different Evaluation Methods,” Werk- stoffe und Korrosion, Vol. 40, No. 4, 1989, pp. 237–242. Williams, D., “Past and Current Practices of Winter Main- tenance at the Montana Department of Transportation (MDT),” White Paper, Helena, Dec. 2003. Wu, X., Inhibition of Catalytic Oxidation of Carbon/Carbon Composite Materials, Ph.D. Dissertation in Materials Sci- ence and Engineering, The Pennsylvania State University, University Park, Dec. 2002. Wu, X., C.G. Pantano, and L.R. Radovic, “Inhibition of Cat- alytic Carbon Oxidation by Boron and Phosphorus,” Pro- ceedings of the International Carbon Conference, Lexing- ton, July 15, 2001, Paper No. P2.33. [Online] Available: http://acs.omnibooksonline.com/papers/2001_P2.33.pdf [accessed July 1, 2007]. Wu, X. and L. Radovic, “Catalytic Oxidation of Carbon/ Carbon Composite Materials in the Presence of Potas- sium and Calcium Acetates,” Carbon, Vol. 43, 2005, pp. 333–344. Wu, X. and L. Radovic, “Inhibition of Catalytic Oxidation of Carbon/Carbon Composites by Phosphorus,” Carbon, Vol. 44, 2006, pp. 141–151. Zhirnov, A.D., S.A. Karimova, L.V. Ovsyannikova, and O.A. Gubenkova, “New Protective Coatings for Replacing Cadmium Coatings on Steel Parts,” Metal Science and Heat Treatment, Vol. 45, No. 1, 2003, pp. 23–25. Zhirnov, A.D., S.A. Karimova, L.V. Ovsyannikova, O.A. Gubenkova, and I.V. Ul’yanov, “Zinc-Based Coatings Instead of Cadmium Coatings,” Korroziya: Materialy, Zashchita, No. 1, 2006, pp. 38–40.