Cover Image

Not for Sale

View/Hide Left Panel
Click for next page ( 12

The National Academies | 500 Fifth St. N.W. | Washington, D.C. 20001
Copyright © National Academy of Sciences. All rights reserved.
Terms of Use and Privacy Statement

Below are the first 10 and last 10 pages of uncorrected machine-read text (when available) of this chapter, followed by the top 30 algorithmically extracted key phrases from the chapter as a whole.
Intended to provide our own search engines and external engines with highly rich, chapter-representative searchable text on the opening pages of each chapter. Because it is UNCORRECTED material, please consider the following text as a useful but insufficient proxy for the authoritative book pages.

Do not use for reproduction, copying, pasting, or reading; exclusively for search engines.

OCR for page 11
11 12-70 Project. Specifically, ground motions associated with the basis also needed to be considered by the NCHRP 12-70 Proj- 1,000-year return period could be used to identify the following: ect or at least be coordinated with future work being done to implement the NCHRP 20-07 Project recommendations: Geographic areas that will not require special seismic design studies. For these areas there will be enough margin in the The shape of the spectrum to be used for design. Significant static design of retaining walls, slopes and embankments, differences in spectral shapes occur between CEUS and and buried structures to accommodate seismic loading, WUS. These differences in spectral shape affect soil response unless special conditions (such as liquefaction) occur. in terms of either peak spectral acceleration or time histories The type of analyses that will be required in more seismically from which design computations or response analyses are active areas. For example, the decrease from the 2,500-year conducted. The previous AASHTO LRFD Bridge Design return period proposed in the NCHRP 12-49 Project to the Specifications made no distinction between spectral shapes 1,000-year return period resulted in smaller increases in within the CEUS and WUS. The updated maps use the ground motions. This meant that nonlinear behavior of soil USGS Seismic Hazard Maps for a 1,000-year return period, was not as significant in any proposed design methodology thereby accounting for differences in spectral shape of as it would have been for the original NCHRP 12-49 Project characteristic earthquakes in CEUS versus WUS. recommendations. The method of introducing site effects on the rock motions developed for the 1,000-year earthquake return periods. The Another important recommendation made as part of the former site categories in the AASHTO LRFD Bridge Design NCHRP 20-07 Project was to follow an NCHRP 12-49 recom- Specifications were too qualitative in description to allow mendation to use the spectral acceleration from a response consistent use. The new site factors followed recommenda- spectrum at 1 second (S1), rather than the PGA, as the param- tions given in the Federal Emergency Management Agency's eter for defining the seismic performance category. The spec- (FEMA) National Earthquake Hazards Reduction Program tral acceleration at 1 second was used for determining both the (NEHRP) reports and the International Building Code level of and the requirement for design analyses. Part of the (IBC) documents, similar to what was recommended by motivation for this change was the observation that damage the NCHRP 12-49 Project and consistent with South Car- olina Department of Transportation (SCDOT) guidelines during earthquakes was better correlated to S1 than to PGA. prepared by Imbsen & Associates. By adopting S1 as the parameter for determining the level of Performance expectation for the retaining walls, embank- and the requirements for design, the region where the thresh- ments and slopes, and buried structures under the 1,000-year old of seismic demand would be sufficiently low to avoid the event. For this event the amount of acceptable deformation need for specialized seismic demand analyses increased. There depended on factors such as the potential consequences of have been significant developments in the seismological com- the deformation (that is, to the retaining wall, roadway munity in the past 10 years which concluded that the seismo- embankment or cut slope, or culvert), the potential need for logical environment in CEUS differs from WUS in regards to and cost of repair, and the additional design requirements the long-period content of earthquake ground shaking. For associated with the performance evaluation. A single set of the same PGA, ground motion records from CEUS have much design guidelines that captured all of these factors was not lower shaking intensity at longer periods of ground motion. easily developed. The choice of using spectral acceleration at 1 second held the potential for minimizing the need for dynamic response analyses for many transportation structures. 2.2 Literature Search In order to simplify integration of the results of the NCHRP Literature reviews were conducted for the three primary 12-70 Project with future editions of the AASHTO LRFD technical areas of the Project: retaining walls, slopes and Bridge Design Specifications, developments resulting from the embankments, and buried structures. The goal of the literature NCHRP 20-07 Project served as the basis when formulating review was to do the following: analysis requirements for retaining walls, slopes and embank- ments, and buried structures. The relevant analysis require- Identify the state-of-the practice in each of the areas of ments included typical levels of ground shaking and spectral consideration, shapes for WUS and CEUS, which then defined the demand Understand the basis for the methods being applied, requirements for completing the design of retaining walls, including their assumptions and limitations, slopes and embankments, and buried structures. Investigate alternative approaches that might be adopted While the preliminary decision on return period addressed during the development of analytical methodologies, one critical design need for the NCHRP 12-70 Project, the Establish some of the desirable features of analytical meth- following additional changes regarding the earthquake design ods that should be considered for development, and