Intended to provide our own search engines and external engines with highly rich, chapter-representative searchable text on the opening pages of each chapter. Because it is UNCORRECTED material, please consider the following text as a useful but insufficient proxy for the authoritative book pages.
Do not use for reproduction, copying, pasting, or reading; exclusively for search engines.
OCR for page 10
10 Hazardous Materials Transportation Incident Data for Root Cause Analysis Table 1-1. Root cause questioning. Question Response Why did the truck run off the road? The driver fell asleep. Why did the driver fall asleep? Driver has sleep apnea. Why were you not aware of this disease? We did not have an up-to-date medical record. Our written procedure did not require us to check if Why did no one check that he had an outdated employees had not updated their medical records medical record? in the last year. five major parameters with key variables under each is presented in Table 1-2, where the con- ditions described in this example are shaded. Note that, in addition to these major parameters, institutional characteristics, such as com- pany financial condition, organizational structure, and safety culture, can play an important role in contributing to accident potential. For the purposes of this study, it is assumed that these con- siderations are embedded in the likelihood that the major parameter variables emerge as causal factors. For example, an organization with a poor safety culture is more likely to utilize a young driver with little experience and an invalid license. Unfortunately, the science on the relation- ship of "company organization" or "safety culture" to safety is still sufficiently new that there is no well-defined set of variables capturing the salient characteristics of "company organization" and "safety culture" that could be implemented feasibly. 1.2 Research Approach For the project, the following research approach was used. 1.2.1 Literature Review The research team examined the literature related to hazmat crash databases, including those that may be dominated by non-hazmat crashes, to determine how the problem of identifying root causes had been addressed in the past. Part of the literature review was aimed at gaining insight into how root cause analysis should be conducted and lessons learned in other research Table 1-2. Accident parameters. Vehicle Driver Packaging Infrastructure Situational Pre-Crash Configuration Age Package Type Road Surface Condition Cargo Body Experience Quantity Shipped Road Condition Dangerous Event GVW Condition Quantity Lost Road Type Vehicle Speed Vehicle Defect Valid License Age (Cargo Tank) Traffic Way Impact Location Rollover Vehicle Response Citation Issued Access Control Primary Reason Protection Driver Response Inspection History Speed Limit Accident Type Design Training No. of Lanes Weather Condition Specification Location Light Condition Time of Day Health Consequences Note: Shading reflects contributing factors to root cause of the hypothetical hazmat tank truck crash described in Section 1.1.