Click for next page ( 26

The National Academies | 500 Fifth St. N.W. | Washington, D.C. 20001
Copyright © National Academy of Sciences. All rights reserved.
Terms of Use and Privacy Statement

Below are the first 10 and last 10 pages of uncorrected machine-read text (when available) of this chapter, followed by the top 30 algorithmically extracted key phrases from the chapter as a whole.
Intended to provide our own search engines and external engines with highly rich, chapter-representative searchable text on the opening pages of each chapter. Because it is UNCORRECTED material, please consider the following text as a useful but insufficient proxy for the authoritative book pages.

Do not use for reproduction, copying, pasting, or reading; exclusively for search engines.

OCR for page 25
improve service quality. In the beginning, several ardship, and even quality and popularity of their data elements were missing or inaccurate. For exam- website. Achievements are reported through the ple, many train delays were falsely attributed to company website and in company literature, as is operator errors because the system could not distin- the achievement of ISO certification in business guish vehicle faults from operator errors. In response, processes. the operations management installed additional vehicle sensors to record all operator control inputs. KMB Taipei Metro management was then able to identify KMB uses a software program to collect and and correct vehicle failures that had been previously analyze data for measuring continuous improve- obscured. ment. Management is responsible for reviewing the data on a monthly basis and holds monthly perfor- REPORTING STRUCTURE mance management meetings to discuss data trends and areas for possible course correction. Hong Kong KMB then provides its stakeholders with exten- MTR sive annual reports that show trends in operational indicators. Some of the common operational statis- MTR produces an interim report, annual report, tical information includes the following: and summary report every year. These reports illus- trate the fiscal health, organizational direction, and Total number of passengers carried for the independent auditor's input. The interim report gives year (ridership), a snapshot. The annual report delves into 10-year Total number of bus routes operated at the end data comparisons, human resources, remuneration, of the year, and reports from top management. MTR's quarterly Fleet size, "Performance Achievements" is a point of pride and Bus kilometers operated for the year, is easily accessible online. A quick glance at the 2008 Total fleet capacity at the end of the year, fourth quarter shows MTR actually exceeded expec- Fleet age, tations in areas such as train service delivery, passen- Achievement of schedule (on-time perfor- ger journey on-time performance, train punctuality, ticket machine reliability, and escalator reliability, all mance), of which scored over 99%. Internally, there are com- Average percentage of lost trips, munications from "top [management] to shop [floor]" Average fleet utilization for the year, and vice versa, all captured by scorecards for the divi- Operational capability--percentage of actual sion, department, and section. number of bus departures compared with Bus licensees compile data and submit it to the scheduled number of bus departures during Transport Department annually, or more frequently peak hours, as they see fit. An example of this is with the report- Average number of bus defects per vehicle for ing of average number of bus defects found during the year, spot checks by the Transport Department. Through Mechanical reliability, annual spot checks, government regulators sample Average number of bus accidents (per million 2% of the entire fleet per week. All modes report on vehicle-kilometers), ridership and headways. Measurements are acces- Total service rationalization items for the year sible on the MTR website, as well as in its annual (frequency reductions, vehicle reductions, and corporate prospectus. Internally, each head of depart- route reorganization), ment sends monthly reports to the board of directors. Total service improvement items for the year, Bus cleanliness reporting is based on direct complaints Average number of customer complaints per lodged, and that is recorded and reported by the mar- million passenger trips, keting and planning groups that study issues concern- Total passenger liaison program (passenger ing ridership. attitude services and user group meetings atten- The well-polished corporate image of these bus dance), and companies is publicized through awards that rec- Bus shelter construction (number of bus shel- ognize their user friendliness, environmental stew- ters available at the end of the year). 25

OCR for page 25
Other operational performance statistics include lights the strategic plan that has been laid out by the revenues, operating cost, profits, and fixed asset Transport Department. reports. In addition, the Transport Department also has a Other avenues for reporting performance include website ( that has a wealth of infor- the KMB website ( The website pro- mation for the general public. vides customers, stakeholders, and employees with vast amounts of information regarding KMB perfor- MTR mance, as well as other corporate information. MTR has very sophisticated mechanisms (tech- Hong Kong Transport Department nology) to report system performance. One of the more significant strategic management performance There are two primary performance reporting systems is the balanced scorecard reporting system. structures in place within the Transport Department. The balanced scorecard was originally used at First, the department holds performance meetings MTR as a test model in the company's engineering with the service providers/franchises to discuss the department because of the readily available data performance indicators in detail. The meetings iden- used for inputs. MTR executive management was tify achievements, as well as shortfalls, and identify very pleased at the results and intrigued with the root causes for performance measures; a discus- possibility of using the balanced scorecard approach sion on continuous improvement is also held. As part for elevating performance and continuous improve- of the license agreement, the Transport Department ment; in 1999, the balanced scorecard was adopted establishes a set of performance indicators for the throughout MTR. franchise companies to report and follow. The per- The MTR balanced scorecard incorporates the formance management system in place ensures that traditional business perspectives, including the finan- all service providers are delivering service according cial, customer, and internal process perspectives. to expectations. There are several categories that are In addition, MTR decided to name their human used to report performance, including reliability (bus capital perspective "efficiency," incorporating availability, lost trips), efficiency (bus utilization), human resource principles. The efficiency perspec- safety, cleanliness, environmental friendliness, and tive includes objectives such as: competent staff, opti- user friendliness (customer complaints, passenger mized manpower, and efficient organization. Because liaison meetings, passenger information at bus termi- MTR is a vital public transportation element in Hong nus, and passenger information at stops). Kong, the company also decided to include a safety Second, the Transport Department has the respon- perspective, with the goal of elevating the safety sibility to provide information to the general public commitments to the public. regarding the status of strategic initiatives outlined in MTR uses the principles of the balanced score- the sustainability plans. Data are collected frequently card to develop its annual reports, announce perfor- to assess strategy effectiveness and to determine mance objectives and measurements on its website future decisions regarding strategic initiatives. The (, and communicate the scorecard Transport Department uses several avenues to dis- results to its own staff. In addition, the balanced seminate information. The Transport Department has scorecard has been extended to the desktop level, so several publications that outline progress of initia- tives. One such publication is Hong Kong Transport that employees understand their contribution to per- 40 Years,7 which outlines a timeline of transport his- formance management. tory and sustainable planning efforts. The second sig- MTR continues its quest for excellence by par- nificant publication is titled A Transport Strategy for ticipating in benchmarking groups such as CoMET the Future: Hong Kong Moving Ahead,8 which high- and Nova. Singapore 7 Hong Kong Transport 40 Years is available at filemanager/en/publication/td-booklet-final-251108.pdf. In Singapore, SMRT uses a more formal (and less 8 A Transport Strategy for the Future: Hong Kong Moving Ahead public) mechanism for reporting performance, con- is available at sisting of a set of monthly meetings held separately publications/hk_move_ahead_txt.htm. for three main areas of reporting: general perfor- 26

OCR for page 25
mance, financial performance, and operations per- Fare gate (downtime no more than 500 hours formance. A monthly report for each of the three per 10,000 hours of operation), areas is then submitted to LTA, the regulator, with the Escalator (downtime no more than 100 hours required detailed performance statistics. per 10,000 hours of operation), On a quarterly basis, the aggregated information Lift (no more than 200 hours per 10,000 hours on SMRT's operating and financial performance is of operation), and published and distributed to the shareholders. SMRT Customer injury rate (no more than 0.4 injuries also reports all of the performance measures in a year- per million customers). end report to shareholders. Since the government of Singapore is the majority shareholder in SMRT, this In addition, PTC also requires SMRT to publish per- report is also functionally a report to the government. formance standards regarding reliability, loading, SMRT is careful to represent the data accurately, but safety, availability, and information/communication. also to present its performance in the best light, high- If performance measures are not adhered to, PTC has lighting important system performance trends over the authority to impose fines on SMRT. the past 5 years and giving particular emphasis to major accomplishments. On the bus side, PTC has quality-of-service stan- Kuala Lumpur dards, which comprise six main factors: operations reliability, passenger loading, safety, service infor- RapidKL compiles performance statistics for a mation, service availability, and service integration variety of purposes. The most important is internal (span of service). These standards are required report- management. Service punctuality (on-time perfor- ing items as part of the operator's route authority. mance), a measurement of actual minutes of delay per Two items, headway adherence and average loading, train, is reported as an annual average in promotional are reported daily. materials, by line. Service reliability (expressed as a LTA demonstrates various ways of communicat- percentage) is also reported annually. Service fre- ing success surrounding the three strategic thrusts. quency is reported as average headway for each of the Because its master plan is a people-centered plan, weekday key time periods (such as morning peak and LTA realizes the importance of keeping the public midday). informed of the progress toward its goals. The master Safety and operating statistics specified as part of plan is posted on the Internet ( the 21 key performance indicators are reported quar- LTMP.html). The LTA website ( also terly to the board of directors and to the government provides a lot of information regarding performance for compliance purposes. RapidKL is currently in the in relation to its strategic initiatives. In addition, process improving the data flow so that monthly there is a quarterly newsletter, called Connect, that reports can be developed for both internal monitor- informs the public about initiatives and conveys ing and external reporting. To comply with its oper- other messages from LTA. LTA's annual report dis- ating agreement with Prasarana, RapidKL must report cusses yearly progress, financial information, and these key indicators, and the indicators must meet the investments. previously agreed-upon targets. The Public Transportation Council is responsible On the bus side, ridership and route productivity for delivering performance measures on bus service. statistics are used internally to make bus route ratio- The PTC also publishes annual reports to demon- nalization determinations. These statistics are cur- strate the performance of the bus service providers in rently also reported annually. Bus ridership has seen Singapore. tremendous growth from 2006 to 2008--reaching SMRT reports a set of agreed-upon rail perfor- 400,000/day, up from 130,000--as a result of fare mance measures to PTC, including the following: initiatives and route restructuring. However, transit Train arrivals (within 2 min of schedule), mode share continues to remain relatively low at Train departures (96% within 2 min of 19% of all metropolitan area trips. Because of on- schedule), going restructuring and investment, the number of Train service availability (at least 96%), buses in the active fleet and the number of bus routes General ticketing machine (downtime no more are seen as important measures of progress and are than 500 hours), reported annually. 27