Cover Image

Not for Sale

View/Hide Left Panel
Click for next page ( 81

The National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine
500 Fifth St. N.W. | Washington, D.C. 20001

Copyright © National Academy of Sciences. All rights reserved.
Terms of Use and Privacy Statement

Below are the first 10 and last 10 pages of uncorrected machine-read text (when available) of this chapter, followed by the top 30 algorithmically extracted key phrases from the chapter as a whole.
Intended to provide our own search engines and external engines with highly rich, chapter-representative searchable text on the opening pages of each chapter. Because it is UNCORRECTED material, please consider the following text as a useful but insufficient proxy for the authoritative book pages.

Do not use for reproduction, copying, pasting, or reading; exclusively for search engines.

OCR for page 80
80 section will focus on travel time reliability and the measures cal conditions. By its very nature, roadway performance is that quantify it. highly variable and unpredictable, in that on any given day, Travel time reliability is the consistency or dependability unusual circumstances such as vehicle accidents can dra- in travel times, as measured from day to day and/or across matically change the performance of the roadway, affecting different times of the day. It better represents a commuter's both travel speeds and throughput volumes. Because travel experience than a simple average travel time measurement. conditions are so unreliable on congested highways, travel- It is important because most travelers are less tolerant of ers must plan for these problems by leaving early to avoid un expected delays (nonrecurring congestion) than of every- being late [2.5.1]. day congestion, and they also tend to remember bad traffic In terms of an agency/operator using this as an internal days over an average daily travel time throughout the year. measure for an APM system, it may not be meaningful because The recommended measures used to quantify travel time airport APM systems tend to have a high level of availability reliability are 90th or 95th percentile travel time, buffer index, and do not have wide variances in the travel times found on and planning time index [2.5.4]. the roadways (i.e., whereas the 90th or 95th percentile travel times for a highway will provide a measurable level of travel time and unavailability over a month's time, an airport APM 90th or 95th Percentile Travel Time system may not). The 90th or 95th percentile travel time measure is sim- ply an estimate in minutes of how bad delays will be on Buffer and Planning Time Indices certain routes during the heaviest traffic days. The 90th or 95th percentile represents those days in the month that are Another effective travel time reliability measure in the the heaviest traffic days causing the greatest congestion and highway industry is the buffer index. The buffer index, pre- longest travel times; it is the near-worst-case travel time. This sented as a percentage, represents the extra time travelers method requires continuous tracking of travel times in order must add to their average travel time when planning trips to provide an accurate estimate. State departments of trans- in order to ensure an on-time arrival most of the time. It portation employ this method for use by the public online. is expressed as a percentage, and its value increases as reli- A traveler can, for example, determine on a website that the ability gets worse. For example, if the average travel time is 95% reliable travel time for a particular route is 59 min, 30 min and the buffer index is 40%, a traveler should allow which means that if the traveler allows 59 min for the trip on an additional 12 min to rely on an on-time arrival 95% of the that route, he or she would be on time 19 out of 20 weekdays time. The extra 12 min is called the buffer time. The buffer in the month [2.5.4]. index is computed as the difference between the 95th per- This measure is ideally suited for traveler information centile travel time and the average travel time, divided by the in that it provides a gauge of how many times in a month, average travel time. for example, the travel time can be relied upon. It does not The planning time index measure represents the total obviously predict the day(s) when the 90th or 95th travel travel time that should be planned for a trip and includes time may occur, but used in conjunction with other mea- an adequate buffer time to rely on an on-time arrival of sures to be described in the following subsections, a reason- 95%. For the previous example, the planning index would able probability of arriving on time can be computed. From be 1.40. The planning time index differs from the buffer the agency's view, this measure may be useful in that it index in that it includes typical delay as well as unexpected can track the creep in the average travel time over a period delay. In addition, where the buffer index is used in deter- of time (i.e., the 59-min travel time may creep to 63 min mining the additional time necessary to make the trip, the over time). This would be useful in planning for the mitiga- planning index is used in determining the total travel time tion of congestion, whether in the form of providing additional necessary for the trip. The planning time index is computed infrastructure or employing other techniques such as HOV as the 95th percentile travel time divided by the average lanes, directional lanes by time of day, or other operational travel time. strategies. In the context of the airport APM industry, it may not be As applied to the airport APM industry, providing this expected that passengers would be traveling daily on an air- measure to the traveling public may not be as useful as in the port APM, nor that the travel time on an airport APM would highway industry since APM travel times tend to be relatively vary to a degree great enough or frequent enough to make short, thereby making the measure less meaningful. In addi- these measures meaningful for use by the public or an APM tion, the high availability of airport APM systems (99%+) owner/operator. The additional time that must be allowed to provides more dependable transportation than a highway make a trip within an established time, or the total time to system, where there is a great variation from average or typi- be allowed for planning a trip within such a time, are mea-