National Academy of Sciences | 150 Year Anniversary

Questions? Call 800-624-6242

| Items in cart [0]

The National Academies Press

PAPERBACK
price:$45.00
add to cart

Rights & Permissions

topleft topright

Not Eating Enough: Overcoming Underconsumption of Military Operational Rations (1995)
Institute of Medicine (IOM)

Citation Manager

. "10 The Role of Image, Stereotypes, and Expectations on the Acceptance and Consumption of Rations." Not Eating Enough: Overcoming Underconsumption of Military Operational Rations. Washington, DC: The National Academies Press, 1995.

Please select a format:

BibTeX EndNote RefMan


Page
178
bottomleft bottomright

The following HTML text is provided to enhance online readability. Many aspects of typography translate only awkwardly to HTML. Please use the page image as the authoritative form to ensure accuracy.


Not Eating Enough: Overcoming Underconsumption of Military Operational Rations

For military food, situational factors related to the conditions under which the food is eaten are, undoubtedly, important. Equally important for military food is the image of the food, as reflected in the attitudes of the individual toward it, his/her expectations for it, and the degree to which the food actually meets those expectations. As shall be shown, each of these variables can be a prepotent factor controlling the acceptability of food its consumption or underconsumption.

RATION IMAGE AND STEREOTYPE

General Public and Media Image

If one were to ask the average person about his or her image of military rations, their response would undoubtedly be a negative one. In fact, a negative image of military rations is widely held among the general public, in spite of the fact that many scientists who are actively engaged in research on military rations—product developers, consumer psychologists, nutritionists, etc. know that the intrinsic quality of rations is quite high. Although the origins of the stereotypical image of rations may be obscure, it is certainly perpetuated by the mass media. Figure 10-1 shows what are perhaps the best examples of this stereotypical image of rations—Beetle Bailey cartoons. Even a casual examination of these cartoons reveals that they impugn all aspects of military rations, including their texture (top panels), their general acceptability (middle panels), and their ingredients and/or nutritional quality (bottom panels).

What is surprising about the cartoons in Figure 10-1 is that they were all taken from the Army Times, the weekly military newspaper read by millions of enlisted soldiers worldwide. Thus, U.S. soldiers are constantly exposed to negative images of rations, even from promilitary media sources. As a result, one of the first issues that must be addressed to better understand the problem of underconsumption of rations is the image of military food as held by its primary consumer group—U.S. soldiers.

Image of Rations Among Military

Figures 10-2 and 10-3, from A. V. Cardello and R. Bell (U.S. Army Natick Research Development and Engineering Center, Natick, Mass., unpublished manuscript, 1995), show data collected from approximately 100 active-duty troops stationed at Fort Devens, Massachusetts, and at Schofield Barracks, Hawaii. Troops were asked, on a written questionnaire, to rate the expected acceptability (Figure 10-2) and the expected quality (Figure 10-3) of 12 different foods when served in each of 7 different military and commercial foodservice facilities.

Page
178
Front Matter (R1-R13)
I Committee Summary and Recommendations (1-2)
1 Introduction and Background (3-40)
2 Conclusions and Recommendations (41-54)
II Background and Introduction to the Topic (55-56)
3 Introduction to the Concepts and Issues: Underlying Underconsumption in Military Settings (57-64)
4 Army Field Feeding System-Future (65-76)
5 Commanders' Perceptions and Attitudes About Their Responsibilities for Feeding Soldiers (77-90)
6 Nutritional Criteria for Development and Testing of Military Field Rations: An Historical Perspective (91-108)
7 Evolution of Rations: The Pursuit of Universal Acceptance (109-120)
8 An Overview of Dietary Intakes During Military Exercises (121-150)
9 The Effects of Ration Modifications on Energy Intake, Body Weight Change (151-174)
III Factors Underlying Food Intake and Underconsumption--Food (175-176)
10 The Role of Image, Stereotypes, and Expectations on the Acceptance and Consumption of Rations (177-202)
11 Effects of Food Quality, Quantity, and Variety on Intake (203-216)
12 Effects of Beverage Consumption and Hydration Status on Caloric Intake (217-238)
13 Industry Approaches to Food Research (239-250)
IV Underconsumption and Performance (251-252)
14 When Does Energy Deficit Affect Soldier Physical Performance? (253-284)
15 Impact of Underconsumption on Cognitive Performance (285-302)
16 The Functional Effects of Carbohydrate and Energy Underconsumption (303-316)
V Factors Underlying Food Intake and Underconsumption--The Eating Situation and Social Issues (317-318)
17 The Physical Eating Situation (319-340)
18 Eating Situations, Food Appropriateness, and Consumption (341-360)
19 From Biologic Rhythms to Chronomes Relevant to Nutrition (361-372)
20 Social Facilitation and Inhibition of Eating (373-392)
21 Lessons from Eating Disorders (393-410)
22 A Plan to Overcome Ration Underconsumption (411-416)
Appendixes (417-418)
A Biographical Sketches (419-432)
B Abbreviations (433-436)
C Factors Related to Underconsumption --A Selected Bibliography (437-464)
Index (465-483)