Questions? Call 800-624-6242
|
|
|
|
|
The following HTML text is provided to enhance online
readability. Many aspects of typography translate only awkwardly to HTML.
Please use the page image
as the authoritative form to ensure accuracy.
Page 211
| TABLE 6.2 Continued
| | I103
| II
| III
| IV
| V
| VI
| VII
| VIII
| | Jurisdiction
| Standard Of Admissibility
| DNA Test
| Method Of Computation
| Opinion As To Source Admissible?
| Only Fact Of Match Admissible?
| Product Admissible?
| Ceiling Admissible?
| | NC
| R
| RFLP
| Product
| | | Yes
| | | Ohio
| R
| RFLP
| Product
| | | Yes
| | | | PCR
| | | | Yes
| | | Okla
| D
| RFLP
| Product
| | | Yes
| | | Ore
| R
| RFLP
| Product
| | | Yes
| | | | PCR
| | | | | Yes
| | Pa
| F
| RFLP
| None
| | Yes
| | | | SC
| F,R
| RFLP
| Product
| | | Yes
| | | SD
| F
| RFLP
| Product
| | | Yes
| | | Tenn
| F,D,R,S
| RFLP
| Product
| | | Yes
| | | Tex
| R
| RFLP
| Product
| | | Yes
| | | | DQA, PCR
| | | | | | | Vt
| D
| RFLP
| Product
| | | No
| Yes
| | | Ceiling
| | | | | | Va
| R,S
| RFLP
| Product
| | | Yes
| | | | DQA
| Product
| | | Yes
| | | Wash
| F
| RFLP
| Product
| No
| | No
| Yes
| | | PCR
| | | | | | | Wisc
| R
| RFLP
| Product
| | | Yes
| Yes
| | | Ceiling
| | | | | | Wyo
| R
| RFLP
| Product
| | | | Yes
| | | Ceiling
| | | | | | 103I. Federal or state jurisdiction in which at least one court opinion on the admissibility of DNA test results that incriminated the defendant was reported. II. Frye (F), Daubert (D), relevance-helpfulness (R), or special statutory (S) standard applied. R refers to cases applying a nonFrye standard adopted before Daubert; all federal courts are now required to apply the Daubert standard. III. Type of DNA test performed. IV. Procedure used to compute probability or frequency offered in the case. V. Is expert-opinion testimony that defendant is the source or that the type is unique admissible? VI. Is only the fact of a match admissible? VII. Is the product-rule estimate admissible? VIII. Is the interim-ceiling-principle estimate admissible?
|
|
|
|