States. Though forum participants indicated that more and more scientists are aware of the need to protect their inventions, university researchers need better guidelines for balancing patent and publishing rights. Some participants noted that universities have an unrealistic expectation that immature technologies will be developed rapidly into useful products by commercial firms. Forum participants agreed that the generation of guidelines for successful technology transfer would improve relationships among research collaborators.

Forum participants represented a continuum of plant science applications ranging from the mature hybrid seed industry to small start-up biotechnology firms. Since 1990 most small genetic engineering firms that developed food and fiber crops have been acquired by larger firms. On the other hand, small biotechnology spin-offs in the phytoremediation sector are beginning to attract the attention of venture capitalists. Participants explained that intellectual property is a strategic tool to increase a firm's competitive advantage. According to those engaged in biobased energy research, since private corporations anticipate eventual returns on their investments, federal funding will continue to be a major component of biobased energy research until marketable products are developed. Forum participants agreed that all three segments of plant science will increasingly depend on industrial funding for basic research underlying the development of biotechnology innovations.

At the forum, academic scientists expressed uncertainty about the effect that strengthened intellectual property rights may have on the future of fundamental plant science. Some argued that strategies developed to protect ideas and data are inhibiting an open laboratory, which is so vital to the discovery process. Others emphasized that access to enabling technologies and genetic material now concentrated in some private firms is crucial to the improvement of most food and fiber crops. Ron Sederoff, speaking for the majority of forum participants, warned that intellectual capital in plant molecular biology is deteriorating. Without increased public funding resources, universities cannot create new knowledge or train scientists. If this trend continues, universities will have little intellectual capital to offer industry. As a result, innovations in plant biotechnology will suffer. Forum participants agreed that government, university, and industry collaborations will benefit from continued exploration of intellectual property rights issues.



The National Academies | 500 Fifth St. N.W. | Washington, D.C. 20001
Copyright © National Academy of Sciences. All rights reserved.
Terms of Use and Privacy Statement