|
Source
|
Type
|
Population
|
Number of Subjects
|
Drug and Dose
|
Duration
|
Outcome/Comments
|
|
Greenblatt et al. (1989)
|
Placebo, active drug
|
Bedtime
|
16
12
13
11
|
Placebo
Flurazepam 15 mg
Temazepam 15 mg
Halcion 0.25 mg
|
Single dose
|
Halcion only hypnotic to initially slow thinking speed. Similar increase above baseline for all but flurazepam at 24 h. Increased thinking speed could be related
|
|
Pinnock et al. (1985)
|
Placebo, diazepam
|
Medical
|
28
30
29
|
Placebo
Diazepam 10 mg
Halcion 0.25 mg
|
Single dose presurgery
|
VAS anxiety diazepam, but not Halcion acutely anxiolytic; no difference 6 h postawakening.
|
|
Kales et al. (1986)
|
Placebo, quazepam; sleep laboratory
|
Insomnia
|
6
6
|
Placebo, Halcion 0.25 mg Placebo, Quazepam 15 mg
|
2 days then 14 days; 3-day withdrawal
|
Carryover sedation with quazepam. (SWS suppression) rebound insomnia with halcion. Rate of "excitatory" effects reported to be 0.5 for Halcion vs. 0.14 for quazepam. Withdrawal-related anxiety/panic for Halcion ("excitatory effects": anxiety, hyperarousal, inability to concentrate, paranoid ideation, nightmares). Not clear that quazepam group was followed long enough to adequately rule out rebound (loss of quazepam).
|
|
Hegelbach-Feller et al. (1988)
|
Placebo, midazepam; crossover
|
Insomnia
|
30
|
Placebo
Halcion 0.5 mg
Midazepam 15 mg
|
11 days
|
More rebound decline in sleep quantity and restlessness during night with Halcion.
|
|
Lee and Lader (1988)
|
Placebo, quazepam; crossover
|
Bedtime
|
12
|
Placebo
Quazepam 15 mg
|
14 days
|
Mild rebound anxiety more clear with quazepam. Withdrawal-related onset of metallic taste with Halcion.
|
|
Fleming et al. (1990)
|
Zopiclone
|
Insomniacs
|
24
24
|
Zopiclone 7.5 mg
Halcion 0.25 mg
|
21 days
|
In first week of withdrawal subjective agitation equivalent: 3 zopiclone, 2 Halcion.
|
|
Mouret et al. (1990)
|
Zopiclone
|
Elderly insomniacs
|
10
|
Halcion 0.25 mg
Zopiclone 7.5 mg
|
15 days.
|
Withdrawal insomnia during treatment with zopiclone but not Halcion; 3 days for Halcion vs. 2 days for zopiclone. Did not see "extremely marked" withdrawal as described by Kales et al. (1976, 1983).
|
|
Elie et al. (1990)
|
Zopiclone
|
Elderly insomniacs
|
44
|
Halcion 0.125 mg
Halcion 0.25 mg
Zopiclone 5 mg
Zopiclone 7.5 mg
|
3 weeks
|
After withdrawal from Halcion, increased sleep latency and decreased sleep soundness end quality for 3 days. No significant change with zopiclone.
|