TABLE 12-1 Studies Reporting on Cholinergic Effects and Fishy Body Odor after Excess Choline Intake
|
Study |
No. of Subjects |
Dose |
Duration (wk) |
Adverse Effects |
|
Growdon et al., 1977aa |
20 |
2 |
Mild cholinergic toxicity: lacrimation, blurred vision, anorexia, and diarrhea. |
|
|
Growdon et al., 1977b |
10 |
8–20 g/dd |
2–17 |
Fishy body odor in all subjects; at 250–300 mg/ kg/d, produced lacrimation, anorexia, vomiting, and diarrhea. |
|
Gelenberg et al., 1979e |
5 |
8–19 g/dd |
6–8 |
100% with fishy body odor after several days; gastrointestinal irritation.f |
|
Lawrence et al., 1980g |
14 |
6 |
At 150 mg/kg/d: 5 of 14 with fishy body odor; 12 of 15 with nausea and diarrhea. |
|
|
a Study involved a double-blind, crossover protocol. b Choline was given as a chloride or bitartrate. c Doses were calculated from data in the report using a reference body weight of 61 kg. Depending on the body weights of the individuals in Lawrence et al. (1980) and Growdon et al. (1977a), the lowest-effect dose may be less than 7.5 g/d. d Choline was given as a chloride. e Nonblinded study; did not include a control group. f Mild, transient Parkinsonian signs (bradykinesia, tremor, and rigidity) were also reported. g Double-blind protocol; included control group. |
||||
because no specific physiological function might be expected to affect sensitivity to excess amounts of choline in older persons, no adjustments are proposed for the elderly.
|
UL for Adults |
19 years and older |
3.5 g/day of choline |
For infants, the UL was judged not determinable because of lack of data concerning adverse effects in this age group and concern