. "4. Strengths and Weaknesses of the Current Regulatory Framework." Genetically Modified Pest-Protected Plants: Science and Regulation. Washington, DC: The National Academies Press, 2000.
The following HTML text is provided to enhance online
readability. Many aspects of typography translate only awkwardly to HTML.
Please use the page image
as the authoritative form to ensure accuracy.
GENETICALLY MODIFIED PEST-PROTECTED PLANTS: SCIENCE AND REGULATION
highlighted in the coordinated framework (OSTP 1986), and the committee has considered each of them in its evaluation of the current status of interagency coordination in regulating transgenic pest-protected plant products. Although all the elements are desirable for promoting coordination, the committee recognizes that they might not all be relevant for every product. The committee also understands that the degree to which some of the elements are achievable is limited by the requirements of the statutes that the agencies administer. The following sections of this chapter discuss those elements outlined in box 4.1.
4.3.3 Consistency of Definitions and Regulatory Scope
To facilitate consistent and efficient regulation, the coordinated framework established the principle that agencies should adopt consistent definitions of regulated products “to the extent permitted by their respective statutory authorities.” An important implication of this principle is that definitions affect the scope of products subject to regulation. Each agency must be cognizant of the scope of products delineated for regulation by its fellow agencies to ensure that regulatory coverage is coordinated and complete, but not unnecessarily duplicative. The committee found that
Although statutory constraints prevent agencies from adopting uniformdefinitions for certain regulatory terms, this does not appear tohave unduly hindered their ability to implement meaningful regulations.
Each agency defines transgenic pest-protected plant products in terms consistent with its regulatory authority: pesticides for EPA, plant pests for USDA, and foods for FDA (table 4.2). The result is that there is no uniform interagency definition of these products. EPA focuses regulatory
TABLE 4.2 EPA, USDA, and FDA Definitions of Regulated Products and Substances
EPA
USDA
FDA
Regulated Product
Plant-pesticide (plant-expressed protectant)
Plant pest, regulated article
Food, feed, food additive
Regulated Substance
Pesticidal substance and genetic material necessary for its production
Organism engineered to contain sequences from plant pests